that "there is a real prospect that such verification can be carried out
successfully in the shortest possible time".[44] Article 9 of the RCD clearly states
that applicants can only be held in detention for "as long as the grounds set out
in Article 8(3) are applicable". This was reiterated by the ECtHR in the case of
Nikoghosyan and others v Poland, when the Court confirmed that the
automatic placement of asylum seekers in detention for six months without
resorting to a stringent individual assessment breached Article 5(1) ECHR.[45] In
the Case of Applicant v State Secretary for Justice and Security, the CJEU
reiterated the importance of monitoring the conditions governing the
lawfulness of detention in the context of asylum.[46] The Court highlighted that
when it is apparent that the conditions governing the lawfulness of detention
have not been or are no longer satisfied, including in situations where the
responsible member state is no longer examining an applicant’s case with due
diligence, the applicant concerned must be released immediately. If an
applicant is not released immediately, the member state risks breaching Article
6 of the CFR and the RCD.[47]
1.3. Conditions and standards of detention
Regardless of whether the circumstances of the CCAC amount to arbitrary
detention and a deprivation of liberty, the conditions and standards in the
CCAC must uphold human dignity. This section does not suggest that any
form of detention of people on the move within the CCAC is permissible or
lawful, but that the conditions and standards within exacerbate the
dehumanising treatment of people on Samos. The de facto detention of people
on the move facilitates the evasion of detention safeguards otherwise
required when an order for detention is issued. In addition to deprivation of
liberty or arbitrary detention – contrary to Article 5 of the ECHR, Article 6 of the
CFR, and Article 9 ICCPR – this report raises concern over the potential breach
of several fundamental rights guarantees of people within the CCAC.
Foremost, Article 1 of the CFR establishes that ‘human dignity’ is not only a
fundamental right but also constitutes the real basis of EU fundamental rights.
_
[44] Directive 2013/33/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 June 2013 on laying
down standards for the reception of applicants for international protection (recast). Preamble 16.
[45] Nikoghosyan and others v Poland [2022] ECHR (App No 14743/17).
[46] Applicant v State Secretary for Justice and Security [2022] CJEU (C-704/20 and C-39/21).
[47] Ibid.
Page 13
Επιλογή στοχευμένης παραγράφου3
Σύνδεση με παράγραφο
Σύνδεση με οντότητα
Απενεργοποίηση επισημάνσεων
Προσθήκη στον πίνακα περιεχομένων