495129
2013
EUC10610.1177/1477370813495129European Journal of CriminologyCheliotis
Special section article
Behind the veil of
philoxenia: The politics
of immigration detention
in Greece
European Journal of Criminology
10(6) 725–745
© The Author(s) 2013
Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/1477370813495129
euc.sagepub.com
Leonidas K Cheliotis
University of Edinburgh, UK
Abstract
This article sets out to summarise the policies, practices and experiences of immigration detention
in contemporary Greece, as well as outlining how they have been critiqued domestically and
internationally. The article proceeds to address the ways in which the Greek state has reacted
to criticisms and pressures for reform, especially from abroad. It is argued that neither domestic
nor international interventions have succeeded in bringing about substantive progressive change
in the Greek immigration detention system. Rather, Greek state authorities have systematically
neutralised criticisms by employing an array of rhetorical techniques, most notably through
evocation of philoxenia (broadly meaning hospitality to foreigners and strangers more generally)
as a natural trait common to all Greeks. In addition to highlighting the dubious and paradoxical
dimensions of the rhetorical defences deployed by the state in Greece, particularly concerning
its discourse of philoxenia, the article goes on to discuss the main socio-political functions that
have subtly been served inside the country’s borders through maintenance of deplorable policies
and practices of immigration detention, including the symbolic management of public anxieties
in accordance with what may be termed the ‘more eligibility’ principle. In pointing to these
functions, the article helps to explain why the Greek state persists in making use of rhetoric that
is blatantly indefensible and bound to attract further disapprobation.
Keywords
Irregular migration, immigration detention, Greece, state responses to criticism, philoxenia,
‘more eligibility’ principle
Despite variation in the ways in which so-called ‘host’ countries in Europe have
responded to migration flows over recent decades, there is no doubt that immigration is
a hot political issue across the continent, both within individual nation-states and at
Corresponding author:
Leonidas K Cheliotis, School of Law, University of Edinburgh, 15 Buccleuch Place, Edinburgh, EH8 9JS, UK.
Email: l.cheliotis@ed.ac.uk
Downloaded from euc.sagepub.com at Oxford University Libraries on November 25, 2013