Unwanted, Unnoticed: an audit of 160 asylum and immigration-related deaths in Europe
groups, but is also a product of the inquest
system, and of the systematic investigation of
all deaths in prisons and immigration removal
centres (IRCs) by the Prisons and Probation
Ombudsman’s office (PPO), which publishes
reports on its website. (The PPO system is in
turn a product of the persistent campaigning over decades by families of those dying in
custody.) In some countries, such as Norway
and Ireland, official statistics are kept, but no
details are revealed as to why or how people
died, and trying to find out is well-nigh
impossible even for the tenacious Irish parliamentarians and refugee support organisations
which have tried. In other countries, such as
Hungary, Greece or Bulgaria, there appear to
be no official records, and with no infrastructure for official accountability, no systematic
monitoring and chaotic reception conditions,
the deaths we have found out about are likely
to be a fraction of the total.
So the deaths we document here are no more
than a snapshot, an indicative fragment of
a larger picture of institutional indifference
and negligence, of inhuman deterrent policies
such as lengthy detention or consignment to a
limbo of enforced dependence and destitution,
where work is forbidden and life is suspended
in waiting.
Of the deaths we have recorded, 123 died as
a consequence – direct or indirect – of the
immigration/ asylum system – by taking
their own lives due to stress placed on them
by the asylum system or prior to deportation,
by medical neglect in detention, by force, or
by meeting accidental deaths through dangerous living conditions, homelessness or
destitution.
Of these:
• 60 committed suicide1. In some cases, it
seems to have been the fear of deportation that triggered suicide, hours or days
before a scheduled removal. In other cases,
detention or the deadly slow asylum process
compounded mental health issues, often
left untreated, driving asylum seekers to kill
themselves, in detention or out of it.
• 26 died – in Belgium, Bulgaria, Germany,
Greece, Italy, Spain and the UK – as a result
of illness, which was either left untreated,
with medical assistance denied or severely
delayed, or inadequately or inappropriately treated, or caused or exacerbated by
conditions in detention, accommodation
and reception centres, or by the threat of
deportation.
Table 2: Factors contributing to immigration and asylum-related deaths of migrants
Suicide
46%
Total (deaths by known causes) = 128
1
2
3
Medical factors1
20%
Destitution
13%
Police
contact2
5% 4% 3%2%
7%
Accidental Non-police Through
homicide
escape3
Postdeportation
‘Medical factors’ refers to deaths resulting from untreated illness, with medical assistance denied or severely delayed, or
inadequately or inappropriately treated. It also includes deaths resulting from medical issues caused or exacerbated by
conditions in detention, accommodation and reception centres, or by the threat of deportation.
‘Police contact’ refers to deaths following direct contact with police or security officials, both privatised and state-employed.
These deaths occurred within detention centres, police stations, during deportation, in homes or on the street, and were the
result of beatings, restraint or shooting.
‘Through escape’ refers to deaths during police chases or immigration raids, in accidents, or those afraid of being arrested who
have thrown themselves from high-storey buildings.
IRR | European Research Progamme Briefing No. 10
4
Επιλογή στοχευμένης παραγράφου3
Σύνδεση με παράγραφο
Σύνδεση με οντότητα
Απενεργοποίηση επισημάνσεων
Προσθήκη στον πίνακα περιεχομένων