Unwanted, Unnoticed: an audit of 160 asylum and immigration-related deaths in Europe
treatment for asylum seekers. A vigorous
campaign by refugee organisations in Ireland
over the deaths in ‘direct provision’ asylum
accommodation has led to the setting up of a
working party to investigate the system and
examine alternatives.
What these campaigns emphasise is that these
deaths are preventable. They are attributable
to an inhumane system which denies dignity
and hope. Like border deaths, these deaths
at the heart of Europe must be counted, and
accounted for,4 both in the sense of giving the
dead names, faces, histories, but also in the
sense of holding states accountable for them,
as a first step to preventing future deaths.
Notes
1. Of these, at least three are disputed, in that there
are allegations that the deceased were beaten to
death by guards. There is an additional death by
overdose which we have not counted as suicide for
lack of information.
2. This figure excludes the three disputed ‘suicides’
above.
3. This figure excludes the accidents and homicides in
Norway referred to above.
4. See Leanne Weber and Sharon Pickering:
Globalisation of borders: death at the global frontier
(2011).
LIST OF DEATHS
AUSTRIA
SNAPSHOT: Austria’s use of police detention centres (PAZ) to hold migrants
and asylum seekers along with criminal
suspects was ended in 2014 following
condemnation by the United Nations
Committee Against Torture (UNCAT) and
the Council of Europe’s Human Rights
Commissioner, and a new, G4S-run dedicated immigration removal centre was
opened.1
• Arslan Duzhiev (37), 11/08/2010
A Chechen asylum seeker, Duzhiev committed suicide in a deportation centre in
Traiskirchen following the failure of three
attempts to have his asylum claim dealt with
in the country. Duzheiv had come to Austria
via Poland earlier in 2010 after a ten-year
ordeal, beginning with a brutal beating in
2000 in Dagestan, Russia by armed men in
military camouflage, who abducted him.
He was sent to prison, where he was unrecognisable to visiting relatives because of
torture and beatings. Following his release he
required lengthy medical treatment and then
left Russia. The Austrian authorities detained
Duzhiev and his family in a deportation
centre for return to Poland under the Dublin
Regulation.2 His repeated failures to overturn
the decision left Duzhiev depressed, paranoid
and fearful of being returned to Russia. He
was found hanged by a rope in his cell.3
• Zelimkhan Isakov (35), 27/09/2012
Another Chechen asylum seeker, Isakov
suffered a fatal heart attack in a deportation centre in Vienna. Isakov claimed to
have spent two years in a Russian concentration camp where he had been tortured
for taking part in the Chechen resistance.
He was arrested in central Vienna for failing
to produce identification documents to the
police, and was detained and threatened with
deportation to Russia despite an ongoing
appeal against the refusal of asylum. In the
detention centre, he had asked for medical
help for pains in his chest and later all over
his body for around two weeks, but received
no medical attention as doctors believed he
was lying to avoid deportation. On 17 March
2014, two doctors were charged with unintentional manslaughter and both were given
150-day prison sentences, later commuted
to €150,000-euro fines.4
IRR | European Research Progamme Briefing No. 10
7
Επιλογή στοχευμένης παραγράφου3
Σύνδεση με παράγραφο
Σύνδεση με οντότητα
Απενεργοποίηση επισημάνσεων
Προσθήκη στον πίνακα περιεχομένων