illegally and forcibly returned to Turkey
by the Greek authorities.41 Moreover, the
Greek National Commission for Human
Rights (GNCHR) intervened by sending
a letter to the Ministry of Citizens’ Protection for each case.
In this chapter we present the pushback
operations of the cases for which GCR
has filed applications for violations of
the ECHR before the ECtHR. We report
the testimonies of the pushback victims as communicated to the ECtHR,
chronologically and relative to the location of the pushback operation (sections A. Evros islets and B. Evros mainland, below, pp. 13,26). Subsequently,
we present two cases where the Turkish
authorities pulled back the asylum seekers from the islets to the Turkish riverbank, indicating the role of the Turkish
authorities in the violent “management”
of migrants at the Evros border (section
C. Pullback Cases, below, pp. 32).
A. EVROS ISLETS
All cases presented below - except
the first - concern the arrival of asylum
seekers on Evros islets and subsequent
pushback operations. The first case
concerns the arrival of different groups
of asylum seekers in the Evros mainland
and their subsequent gathering, forced
transfer and abandonment by the Greek
authorities on an Evros islet as part of
the pushback operation. We present all
cases under the same Chapter “Evros
Islets” to underline the shift in the illegal
Greek state practice.
In 2021, Amnesty International documented incidents of Greek and Turkish
authorities forcing asylum seekers onto
islets in the river Evros, likely as a tactic to eschew responsibility for them
and their safety.42 A similar practice of
forced transfer, placement and abandonment of asylum seekers in places
with no means of safe escape and survival has been documented in the Aegean Sea, when the Greek coast guard
transferred and abandoned the asylum
seekers on a rocky islet.43
The first pushback case (to an islet)
presented below is indicative of this
tactic, while the next pushback cases (from the islets) reveal a change
in tactic following the issuance of the
first interim measures decision of the
ECtHR that ordered the Greek State
to immediately rescue the people
stranded on the islet, acknowledging
its legal responsibility to do so. After
this decision, we notice that the Greek
authorities push people back to the
Turkish riverbank instead of transferring them on Evros islets, which
ECtHR decisions in many cases have
recognized as areas under the Greek
State’s responsibility for search and
rescue.
I. The emblematic pushback case from
the Evros mainland to an islet - before
the shift of the pushback practice
GCR, Information Note on interventions and on interim measures granted by the ECtHR in cases
regarding pushbacks,http://bit.ly/3fmraBB
41
42
Amnesty International, Greece: Violence, Lies and Pushbacks, June 2021, available at: https://bit.
ly/3H50G36
Wearesolomon, Dark Water of the Aegean: 1,018 illegal pushbacks carried out by the Greek State, 15
July 2022, available at: https://bit.ly/3H4f4Zp
43
AT EUROPE’S BORDERS: BETWEEN IMPUNITY AND CRIMINALIZATION
13
Επιλογή στοχευμένης παραγράφου3
Σύνδεση με παράγραφο
Σύνδεση με οντότητα
Απενεργοποίηση επισημάνσεων
Προσθήκη στον πίνακα περιεχομένων