In other countries, the term “first” or “initial” reception is even less straightforward. The Austrian reception system,
at the outset underpinned by complex interactions between federal-level accommodation and provincial responsibilities, contains a number of federal reception centres (Bundesbetreuungstellen) for the initial accommodation of
asylum seekers. These include initial reception centres (EAST) which until 20 July 2015 were the only competent
branches of the asylum authority (BFA) to register asylum applications and conduct admissibility procedures for
asylum seekers.19 The two EAST, Thalham and Traiskirchen, are now redirected to mainly handling Dublin cases
and admissibility procedures for unaccompanied children. As of 20 July 2015, the first reception of applicants
occurs in the EAST for the aforementioned cases, while other cases are received in one of the newly established
distribution centres (VQ) or other federal reception centres.20 In that regard, the notion of “initial reception centre”
in the Austrian asylum system no longer carries the connotation of first-line reception, but rather implies that the
person hosted therein falls within a Dublin procedure or is an unaccompanied minor undergoing an admissibility
procedure.
Other asylum systems draw no formal divide between short- and longer-term reception facilities, though such a
difference exists in practice. For instance, Hungary’s Nagyfa, a centre near Szeged and the Serbian border, consisting of heated containers hosting up to 300 persons, was set up in January 2015 and initially functioned as a
“distribution centre”,21 from where asylum seekers were transferred to other centres throughout the country after
a maximum stay of 2 days. Since September 2015, the centre has been formally turned into a regular reception
facility,22 yet without undergoing any alterations or improvements with a view to accommodating asylum seekers
for longer periods. In essence, there is little in practice to suggest that Nagyfa has transitioned from a first reception
facility to a longer-term one.
1.2. What is not reception: confinement and detention
Another conceptual boundary whose clarity in principle is not always mirrored in practice is that separating reception from detention of asylum seekers. The recast Reception Conditions Directive delineates their respective
scope by defining any confinement of a person to a specific place where he or she is deprived of his or her liberty
as “detention”.23 In addition, Article 18 of the Directive outlines the modalities of material reception conditions
“without prejudice” to the specific accommodation regime applicable in detention.24 These provisions imply that
reception and detention are easily distinguishable legal and factual spheres, triggering equally distinguishable
obligations on the part of Member States.
Yet, the line between open accommodation and confinement often becomes difficult to draw in practice. This has
formed a contentious issue in human rights law as early as the Amuur v France judgment of the European Court
of Human Rights (ECtHR).25 Twenty years after the Strasbourg Court’s firm position that, contrary to states’ submissions, confining an asylum seeker in an airport transit zone amounts to deprivation of liberty under Article 5
of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), the legality of certain ‘accommodation’ practices across
Europe remains controversial. Reminiscent examples may be drawn from transit zones in international airports
in Germany,26 the Netherlands27 or Serbia,28 where asylum seekers are not considered to be detained (while
Switzerland concedes that asylum seekers are effectively detained in airports),29 as well as transit zones in land
borders such as those established in Hungary after September 2015.30
More recently, the “hotspot” approach has introduced greater ambiguity in the reception/detention divide. In Italy, non-governmental organisations have denounced “hotspot” facilities such as Pozzallo inter alia for confining
people to a state of detention and preventing them from exiting the centre.31 In the case of Greece, “hotspots”
established on the Aegean islands comprise First Reception Centres managed by the First Reception Service, as
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
12
Former Article 17 Austrian Asylum Act.
Articles 42 and 42 Austrian BFA Procedures Act. For a detailed overview, see ECRE, Navigating the Maze: Structural
barriers to accessing protection in Austria, available at: http://bit.ly/1OR2fjy, December 2015, 10-11.
EASO, Description of the Hungarian asylum system, June 2015, 4, 7.
AIDA Country Report Hungary: Fourth Update, November 2015, 50.
Article 2(h) recast Reception Conditions Directive.
Article 18(2) recast Reception Conditions Directive. Detention triggers specific duties on states, which are governed by
Articles 8-11 of the Directive.
ECtHR, Amuur v France, Application No 19776/92, Judgment of 25 June 1996.
AIDA Country Report Germany: Fourth Update, November 2015, 34.
AIDA Country Report Netherlands: Fourth Update, November 2015, 53.
AIDA Country Report Serbia, March 2016, 37.
AIDA Country Report Switzerland: First Update, October 2015, 70.
For a discussion of the Röszke transit zone, see ECRE, Crossing Boundaries: The new asylum procedure at the border
and restrictions to accessing protection in Hungary, October 2015, available at: http://bit.ly/1KD4Wyf.
Oxfam, ASGI, A Buon Diritto, ‘Negli hotspots gravi violazini dei diritti dei migranti’, 12 December 2015, available in Italian
at: http://bit.ly/1KCtXAH. This is corroborated by the Lasciate CIE Entrare campaign.
Επιλογή στοχευμένης παραγράφου3
Σύνδεση με παράγραφο
Σύνδεση με οντότητα
Απενεργοποίηση επισημάνσεων
Προσθήκη στον πίνακα περιεχομένων