Chapter I: RECEPTION IN TERMS & FIGURES 1. What is “reception”? Categories and unclear boundaries In the absence of a clear definition, reception can carry different meanings and legal weight in the asylum and migration context. The EU asylum acquis makes reference to different forms of reception conditions made available to asylum seekers, including material conditions (housing, food, clothing, vouchers, financial allowances), health care, employment and education.7 When seen in practice, however, these conditions prove to be implemented in widely different ways from one country to another, or even within the same country. To that end, clarifying the concept of reception is necessary to ensuring a better understanding of states’ obligations and of the ways these are complied with. Particular emphasis is placed on the issue of accommodation in this regard. 1.1. First-line and second-line reception: clear lines? The distinction between first- and second-line reception is not formally drawn in the EU legal framework. While the concept of “first reception” appears across several European asylum systems, the meaning attached thereto may differ considerably from one country to another. Some states draw clear institutional distinctions between the framework of “first reception” as hosting of new arrivals, on one hand, and second-line reception as accommodation of persons who have entered the asylum procedure on the other. Greece, for instance, entrusts responsibility for the two tasks to different governmental authorities. The First Reception Service (soon Reception and Identification Service), under the responsibility of the Ministry of Interior, handles all aspects of “effective management of irregularly entering third-country nationals”.8 This involves the overall management of First Reception Centres, which include the existing and prospective “hotspots” to be set up on the Aegean islands.9 The First Reception Centres in Greece conduct identification and nationality screening, medical screening, a basic provision of information, and referrals,10 similar to the functions of the ones foreseen in Malta11 or Turkey.12 On the other hand, responsibility for the longer-term reception of applicants for international protection currently lay within the purview of the Greek Ministry of Labour, Social Security and Social Solidarity,13 and will be under the responsibility of the Directorate of Reception and Social Integration – a different directorate – at the Ministry of Interior.14 This institutional divide helps theoretically to discern short-stay accommodation designed for the newly arrived, which may not exceed 28 days, from accommodation provided to asylum seekers who navigate the procedure, often for lengthy periods of time.15 Conversely, more complex arrangements have been put in place in Italy. The amended legal framework of the reception system draws a (theoretical) line between first reception on one hand, generally provided for a maximum of 30 days in Regional “Hubs”,16 and second-line reception provided under the System for the Protection of Asylum Seekers and Refugees (SPRAR) on the other. However, in contrast to the Greek approach, the Italian system includes both forms of reception in the legislative instrument regulating reception of asylum seekers.17 This design seems to reflect pre-existing practice in Italy, whereby asylum seekers were likely to stay in CARA or other firstline reception structures throughout the entire asylum procedure,18 even though the quality of reception conditions differs considerably between those types of accommodation and SPRAR facilities. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. Articles 2(g) and 14-19 recast Reception Conditions Directive. Article 6 Greek Law 3907/2011, as proposed for amendment in February 2016. See Greek Joint Ministerial Decision 2969/2015 “Establishment of First Reception Centres and temporary Accommodation Facilities for asylum seekers and vulnerable groups of third-country nationals”, Official Gazzette 2602/B/2-12-2015. Article 7 Greek Law 3907/2011, as proposed for amendment in February 2016. Maltese Ministry of Home Affairs and National Security, Strategy for the reception of asylum seekers and irregular migrants, December 2015, available at: http://bit.ly/1Wb3Cej, 10. See Turkish Temporary Protection Regulation. However, such first reception centres have not been established in Turkey to date: AIDA Country Report Turkey: First Update, December 2015, 114. AIDA Country Report Greece: Fourth Update, November 2015, 74. Article 13 Greek Draft Law amending Law 3907/2011. It is worth recalling that the EU acquis foresees a 6-month deadline for a normal asylum procedure to be completed: Article 31(3) Directive 2013/32/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 June 2013 on common procedures for granting and withdrawing international protection (recast), OJ 2013 L180/60. The term “Hub”, introduced in September 2015 by the Italian Legislative Decree 142/2015, encompasses reception centres for asylum seekers (CARA) and accommodation centres (CDA). See Articles 9-14 Italian Legislative Decree 142/2015. AIDA Country Report Italy: Fourth Update, December 2015, 74. 11

Επιλογή στοχευμένης παραγράφου3

Σύνδεση με παράγραφο
Σύνδεση με οντότητα
Απενεργοποίηση επισημάνσεων
Προσθήκη στον πίνακα περιεχομένων