games played by detention staff at the expense
of detainees, regardless of their vulnerable state.54
BVMN affirms that these types of psychological
abuse could amount to degrading treatment, on
the grounds that they are reported as intentful acts
and considering the respondent’s expressions of
the intensity of humiliation experienced.
Respondent 15, Iraq. Detained in Amygdaleza
PRDC.
So there is violence, but it is not the common one
which is the physical violence. It’s a psychological
violence because they keep you there for no reason
and you don’t know why or when you get out. You
have no clue why you are there. So, a lot of people
got affected from this because do you know why
they are there?
There is one guy from like Middle Africa. He was
really in a not a good state. So he was telling them,
“I want to go to France. Don’t keep me here. I wanna
be free” and they told him “yeah tomorrow you will
get out of this place. You will be free tomorrow,”
so he grabbed all of his stuff and he went next to
the fence and he was waiting there, to be free the
next day. So he spent the whole day there waiting
and probably slept and came back just to get out
and when they came in the morning he told them.
“You won’t let me free now? I’ve been waiting since
yesterday.” Then they just laughed at him, he said.
“Really, you believe that now you have nowhere to
go.” Then he tried to hurt himself by climbing the
fence. Then they went inside. They told him let’s go
with us. They put him in the car. They took him to a
place beating him up where nobody saw that. And
then took him to a separate, police-like, cell. You
know he was staying alone there in the cell for one
month. Then, they got him out.
Respondent 4, Algeria. Detained in Paranesti
PRDC.
One time when he was in Drama a guy was asking
to go to the hospital and they took him because
he ate some knives, small knives (razors) because
he wanted to go. And when they took him to the
hospital he managed to escape, they tried to find
him, did not find him and came back to detention
and went to his room and were looking for his
phone and when they did not find the phone they
just beated the respondent and everyone up. He
was sleeping and they opened the door and beat
him.
While some respondents also reported on
incidents of violence between detainees, it often
came with a caveat that it was only a result of the
structural violence that they were experiencing
regarding their situation. According to testimonies,
the general state of severe psychological suffering
of detainees manifested in tensions between
each other. This was particularly the case in
overcrowded spaces - for example regarding
individuals detained in police stations - or when
individuals were detained for prolonged periods
in poor conditions. According to previous cases
at the ECtHR, individuals subjected to “hardship
going beyond the unavoidable level of suffering
inherent in detention” are subject to a violation of
Article 3, ECHR.55 Therefore, obligations regarding
detention conditions have been imposed on states,
including cleanliness, size of cells, ventilation,
heating and electricity as well as bedding.56
However, respondents frequently reported on the
lack of dignity provided by detention conditions
and testified to the reality of these standards
not being met which, as a result, contributes to
detention centres becoming sites which amplify
tensions, as well as the psychological and physical
suffering of people on the move.
Respondent 6, Togo. Detained in Corinth PRDC.
And they... it has made that place like a jungle. If
you are not strong, you cannot survive. Because if
somebody can beat you, he just, because we are
almost all of us, like, let me say depressed. Because
of what we are going through. So with little, small
things we just start to fight. Small things, we fight.
So someone can just maybe mistakenly step on
your leg and that will become a big fight. And the
police, they are not going to come and separate us
or something.
Respondent 12, Afghanistan. Detained in Corinth
PRDC.
I think the main problem with the people there is
they fight with each other. It could be lots of things
but sometimes they fight for a shower, they fight for
room, they fight for everything. Also, because they
are really experiencing a hard situation, they are
waiting for a long time, for more than 10 months,
so they really get mental health problems and they
can’t control themselves and fight with each other.
They can do nothing else.
Verbal aggression and racist
insults
A clear pattern of verbal aggression, including
the use of racist and discriminatory insults toward
detainees was evident in our testimonies, with
25% of respondents reporting specifically on this.
This verbal abuse fed into respondents general
feelings of being treated like ‘animals’ and
‘criminals’ which, particularly over time, resulted in a
deterioration of mental health. The Greek National
Commission for Human Rights (GNCHR) has also
acknowledged extensive evidence of racist and
xenophobic violence toward refugees and asylum
seekers in Greece, through their Racist Violence
Recording Network (RVRN).57 This indicates a
16
Επιλογή στοχευμένης παραγράφου3
Σύνδεση με παράγραφο
Σύνδεση με οντότητα
Απενεργοποίηση επισημάνσεων
Προσθήκη στον πίνακα περιεχομένων