because it is very costly and causes losses not only to the offender but to society as a whole. As
a rule, milder punishments should therefore be preferred.
Greece's indiscriminate detention policy falls behind in terms of cost-effectiveness on several
fronts.
First, it exceeds Greece's current budget. In particular, the average cost of detaining an irregular
migrant in Greece is 16 euros/per day,91 of which 5,87 euros are invested in daily food catering.
Compared to other EU Member States, the overall sum is very low92 and does not suffice to
secure the basic needs of the detainees.93 In fact, NGOs often provide detainees with basic items
out of their own resources. 94 Nonetheless, on the basis of the current capacity of pre-removal
centres (4,985), detention costs Greece and the EU a minimum of EUR 28,713,600 per year
(excluding special holding facilities, police stations and border guard units). Greece's plan is to
create a total of 7,500 places of detention, 95 which would entail a minimum annual cost of EUR
43,200,000.
To compare, in 2013 alone, Greece's return policy (pre-removal centres and return operations)
ran under a total budget of EUR 46 million (EU funding and national resources). This means that
the available funds are insufficient to carry the costs of such an expanded and expansive
detention policy and practice.
Second, the cost of detention weighs heavily within the Return Fund scheme. Approximately
32 % of the allocation has so far been consumed to cover costs related to detention facilities,
in order to improve their conditions. Given Greece's other needs, in the end only 50% was left
to operate actual returns. 96 If we add to this the planned annual running costs, EUR 43,2
million, then Greece will have to seriously cut down on its other operations incorporated in the
European Return Fund to carry out its planned detention policy.
91
Calculated on the basis of the annual running costs of pre-removal centres divided by their capacity, as in
Ministry of Citizen Protection, Revised National Action Plan on Asylum and Migration Management, Chapter 4, 2013. See
also Joint Ministerial Decision No 2/30866/0022 by the Ministers of Finances and of Public Order, dated 12.7.2001; See
also Minister of Citizen Protection, Parliamentary Reply of 03 February 2014 available at
http://www.hellenicparliament.gr/UserFiles/67715b2c-ec81-4f0c-ad6a-476a34d732bd/8341922.pdf
92
For a comparative overview of the different detention regimes among EU Member States see Global Detention
Project, “Europe Profiles”, available at http://www.globaldetentionproject.org/countries/europe.html
93
See Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, “Report to
the Greek Government on the visit to Greece from 4 to 16 April 20130”, 16 October 2014, available at
http://www.cpt.coe.int/documents/grc/2014-26-inf-eng.pdf
94
Interview with Medecins sans Frontieres, 5 May 2014
95
The original plan was to create 10,000 places of detention by the end of 2014. See Commission Staff Working
Document on the Assessment of the implementation of the Greek Action Plan on Asylum and Migration management, 6
October 2014
96
Commission Staff Working Document on the Assessment of the implementation of the Greek Action Plan on
Asylum and Migration Management, 2014, p. 14
Page
46