From the “Jungle” to the “Prison”
Two years ago, in February 2020, the previous Reception and Identification Center
(RIC) on Samos housed about 7,200 people – nearly 10 times its capacity.3 These
overcrowded conditions resulted in many people living in makeshift tents in inhuman and degrading conditions, in the wider forest area known as the "jungle".4 The
previous RIC was about 400 meters from the city center and within a 10-minute
walk, asylum seekers could have access to essential services and goods, interact
with the local society and engage in social activities. Although conditions were
still inhumane, before the pandemic, asylum seekers were able to move freely in
and out of the camp.
Now, two years later, Samos has become a center for reports 5 and complaints6 of
illegal pushbacks. The island only hosts 372 people seeking asylum 7 in the new
camp, located in the remote Zervou area. The new Closed and Controlled Facility
or camp has a capacity of 3,000 residents, including 900 in the pre-removal detention section that has not been yet operational. The camp is heavily fortified and
guarded 24/7 by the Greek police and a private security company. 8 It is surrounded
by two layers of barbed wire and has additional internal fences between its different areas; with even the kindergarten being surrounded by fences. To walk from
container to the administrative services’ office inside the camp, residents must
pass through a gate manned by a security officer and submit to a security check
and have a metal detector bodily check. There are security guards patrolling elevated observation posts and monitoring a closed-circuit surveillance system9 with
camera surveillance and motion analysis algorithms monitoring the behaviour and
movement of residents inside the camp. This level of supervision, which is fully
funded by the EU, could be viewed as an invasion of an asylum seekers’ right to
private and family life.10
To enter and exit the camp, residents have to go through turnstiles, magnetic gates,
x-rays and pass through a two-factor access control system (electronic card and
fingerprint). In addition, each time camp residents return, they are subjected to
body and bag searches and pass again through a metal detector.11 Even children
attending school, are forced to undergo this exhausting screening twice a day. According to the General Regulation on the operation of Islands’ CCACs, residents
are only allowed to exit and enter the camp during a specific window of time. In
case of absences or lateness, those residents can be punished with a decision of
termination of residence and the material reception conditions provided, meaning
cash assistance and food.12 Legal aid organizations operating on Samos report
cases where the security guards did not let a resident enter the site as he was
absent for one day without notice, where the administration rejected a resident’s
request without justification for a few days-absence for personal reasons, and
where the administration did not approve the exit for residents to go to work or
volunteer.
These instances raise concerns that the administration and security service of the
camp are arbitrarily preventing exit without following official procedures, without
written justified decisions, and in violation of procedural safeguards and residents’
rights.
Lawyers supporting asylum seekers through their asylum application process report incidents where they had to wait for unreasonable time at the gate for their
entrance to be approved and/or that they were being followed by security guards
while visiting their clients inside the camp. Additionally, a resident reported that
when journalists visited the facility, they were accompanied by security guards, and
residents did not feel free to express their views. MSF reported that the majority of
their mental health patients on Samos present symptoms of depression and PTSD
and denounced the deterioration of these people’s mental and physical well-being
in the new closed camp.13
3
“Since November, we don’t
have the right to exit; it is like
living in a prison. The only
thing that changed comparing
to the old camp, the only improvement is that here we live
in containers; for the rest, the
new center is worse; we don’t
have our freedom, we are prisoners here.”
-A. Afghan Mother, trapped
on Samos since 2019