42
making it difficult to track and report on the
guard. From there, people eventually undergo
precise practices. Immediately following the
reception and identification procedures and
end of the automatic detention scheme—
are later issued an asylum seeker’s card. Only
around September 2021—Equal Rights
once they receive the asylum seeker’s card can
observed the following practice: after
they exit the CCAC, an event that actors on Kos
quarantine, new arrivals underwent reception
report takes place in some cases before and
and identification procedures, in many cases
others after the 25-day restriction order
completing these procedures in one day. At the
expires.
end of their registration procedures, RIS issued
all newly registered asylum seekers an order
that restricted their liberty for up to 25 days.
Although in many cases they had already
finished their reception and identification
2. Legal Assessment
The practices on Kos surrounding the 25-day
restriction of freedom order raise numerous
legal issues relevant to this report.
procedures at that point, the order was
From the outset, the “restriction of liberty”
enforced in its entirety during this period,
indisputably amounts to a deprivation of
meaning that people could not leave the RIC or
liberty and therefore detention. This is clear
CCAC for the full 25 days for any reason.
from Art. 40 itself, which explains that “the
Starting sometime in October 2022, the policy
restriction of liberty shall entail a prohibition
shifted and the Director of the CCAC began
on leaving the Reception and Identification
allowing people to exit once they had their
Centre or the Closed Controlled Access Centre
asylum seeker’s card, regardless of whether
and on remaining on their premises.”115
they were still under the 25-day restriction
With that in mind, the practice on Kos often
order. However, the Director of the CCAC never
formally revoked the decision but rather
instituted the policy informally.
amounts to unlawful and arbitrary detention.
First, Art. 40 explains that asylum seekers
should be subject to reception and
In January 2023, Equal Rights observed that
identification procedures “being under a
the policy had once again shifted and new
restriction of their freedom within the Centre”
practices were in place. Under the current
by a decision issued within five days of entry.
practices, new arrivals undergo the FRONTEX
If, at the end of that five-day period, reception
registration on the same day or shortly after
and identification procedures are still ongoing
their arrival. Following their FRONTEX
than the Director of the CCAC may issue an
registration, the Director of the CCAC issues
order extending the restriction of liberty for a
people a 25-day restriction order before
period not exceeding 25 days in total.116
conducting their reception and identification
However, in its more than two years operating
procedures. Asylum seekers are then moved to
on Kos, Equal Rights has never come across an
a specific section in the CCAC—at the time of
initial five-day order, only a single order
writing areas A1 and A2—from which they
restricting applicants’ liberty for up to 25 days.
cannot exit for any reason except for in case of
Second, and most importantly, for the majority
emergency and if accompanied by a security
of the reporting period RIS issued the 25-day
115
Art. 40 L. 4939/2022.
116
Art. 40(a) L. 4939/2022.
‘Still detained and forgotten’ – Update on Detention Policies, Practices, and Conditions on Kos 2022/23