“I was walking alone along the train rails in the dark.
The police appeared … they started beating me up.”
“Fear… fear… fear!”
“I was walking alone along the train rails in the dark. The police appeared …
they started beating me up.”
always the same. The violence that refugees
and immigrants encounter today is daily, both
physically and psychologically, and perhaps it
is a precursor of the violence that we will all
encounter as our society becomes more authoritarian and callous.” 23
As members of the "Motion for the defense of
refugees‘ and immigrants‘ rights" stressed to
us during a meeting held in April, 2012, often
migrants and refugees are literally haunted by
police officers on motorcycles and have sometimes been seriously injured while jumping
from the upper floors or roofs of the buildings
where they find temporary refuge.
In 2007, the Group of Lawyers for the
Rights of Migrants and Refugees and Pro Asyl,
in their report “The truth may be bitter, but it
must be told” (p. 28f) documented cases of illtreatment by the police in Patras. Among them,
there were cases of beatings with electric batons and of ill-treated minors.
In 2008 Human Rights Watch in “Left to
Survive: Systematic failure to protect unaccompanied migrant children” reported: “Many
of the unaccompanied children, in addition
to numerous adults, interviewed by Human
23 P
ress Release by Kinisi 13.10.2011 (translated by Pro
Asyl): http://www.kinisipatras.gr/index.php?option=com_cont
ent&view=category&layout=blog&id=14&Itemid=62&lang=en
Rights Watch, described violence and ill-treatment at the hands of police, port police, coastguards or border guard taking place during
interception at sea and during arrest or detention”. These cases included an Afghan minor
referred to the Greek Ombudsman in 2008 24
who was stabbed with a knife by a port official.
(p.36) Other significant cases include the mock
execution to which police subjected another
Afghan minor named Ghulam S (p. 35) and Jafar
F, who was thrown into the sea by officers from
the port authority.
In 2010 the European Committee on the
Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT) interviewed a detainee interviewed in the Gounari
Street police station in Patras, who was alleged
to have been ill-treated by the police after his
arrest (p.17). “A detained person interviewed at
Patras Gounari Street Police Station alleged to
have been punched in the eye and nose on 19
September 2009 by a police officer after having
been apprehended.” (p. 17)
24 P
ress Release by the Greek Ombudsman:
www.synigoros.gr/resources/docs/200877.pdf
Press Release by the Greek Ombudsman:
www.synigoros.gr/resources/_deltio_stp_8_2.pdf
Letter to the Authorities by the Ombudsman:
www.synigoros.gr/resources/_patra_katavlismos_8_2-2.pdf
Doctors of the World, who were running a
program of medical aid in Patras during the
summer of 2011 and who are about to start a
new program in Patras this summer stated in a
Press Release (28.07.2011): “Médecins du Monde notes with great concern the persistent use
of violence against immigrants – regular or not
- who are caught up in the port city of Patras
in a desperate situation while trying to leave
Greece. Blows from batons into the extremes
or genitals and severe head injuries are some
examples of physical police violence recorded
by the doctors of the organization. The use of
physical force, without the following “excuse”
of being part of the arrest, constitutes an illegal and inhumane abuse of power. Additionally,
Médecins du Monde denounces the exclusion
of refugees and other persons in need of assistance from the mobile medical unit of the
organization. This exclusion violates the right
to medical care. We want to point out the paradox of state organs undermining the activities
of NGOs that are financed by the Greek State
itself.
Médecins du Monde has evidence proving all
the above and states that it will uphold defend
the right to decent survival and will do whatever it takes to turn it into practice.” 25
On February 21, 2012 the Racist Violence
Recording Network in Athens and Patras,
which was set up at the initiative of the National Commission for Human Rights (NCHR)
and the Office of the UN High Commissioner
for Refugees in Greece (UNHCR) with the participation of 18 non-governmental organizations
and other bodies, reported eight cases of racist
violence against migrants perpetrated by police officers in Patras between October and December 2011. 26
25 P
ress Release 28.07.2011 (translated by Pro Asyl): https://
athens.indymedia.org/front.php3?lang=en&article_id=1323055
26 Racist Violence Recording Network / I-RED reported:
“There is a distinct category consisting of 18 incidents,
where police and racist violence are interlinked (10 in
Athens and 8 in Patras). These incidents concern duty
police officers, who resorted to illegal acts and violent
practices while carrying out routine operations. There
are a few recorded cases of migrants and asylum seekers
taken to police stations, where they were detained and
maltreated during a certain number of hours, as well
as cases where legal documents were destroyed during
these operations.”
Source: http://www.1againstracism.gr/index.php/en/component/k2/itemlist/category/26-racist-violence-recording-network
Following a fact-finding mission (29.02.02.03.2012) the Greek Council for Refugees reported: “Complaints often concerned incidents
where migrants were forced into the sea, with
their clothes on and in freezing weather conditions, to stay in cold water up to their necks
and then once out of the water were made to
stand still for hours in their wet clothes, until
they freeze (...). In addition, there were reports
of migrants who were forced to stay on their
hands and knees, while port authority officers
would sit on them. In other cases, the victims
were forced to take off their clothes, stand still
with their legs extended, and beaten every time
they moved. Furthermore, as we have been told,
the authorities often destroy or confiscate migrants’ personal belongings – even food or their
shoes. The port officers unleash their dogs, sometimes leading to serious injuries from dog
bites or falls when migrants try to escape them.
There have also been some isolated reports of
falls from the upper floors of buildings -served
as makeshift shelters- during police raids.
On the afternoon of 29.2.12 members of our
mission-team witnessed the beating of an 18
year old Afghan by a police officer in a supermarket carpark not far away from the Peiraiki
Patraiki factory. The policeman took the Afghan to a more isolated place and repeatedly
kicked him in the shins. He then took away his
plastic bag, with his milk and bread. We would
like to highlight the fact that all refugees unanimously expressed their desire and need for
protection from police violence.” 27
On April 24, 2012 HRW wrote on its Observations to the UN Special Rapporteur against
Torture, about further cases of ill-treatment in
Patras documented by them during their factfinding missions in late November/early December 2011: “Human Rights Watch spoke with
seventeen migrants, including ten unaccompanied Afghan migrant children, who told us
of police and Coast Guard abuse. These abuses
occurred on the streets, during sweeps in the
abandoned factory where they lived during our
visit, and in the port area during attempts to
hide under or inside trucks heading to Italy.” 28
27 P
ress Release by GCR 2012 (translated by Pro Asyl).
See: www.gcr.gr
28 http://www.hrw.org/news/2012/04/25/updated-human-rightswatch-submission-united-nations-committee-against-torturegreec
15