V
3. Ill-Treatment
against
migrants and refugees
by state agents
iolence and ill-treatment by law
enforcement officers in Patras
includes wanton physical force,
verbal attacks and psychological
i ntimidation.
Victims of such violence often belong to relatively powerless groups, such as minorities, the
disabled, the young, and the poor, as well as refugees and migrants. In his annual report, the
United Nations Special Rapporteur on Torture
noted that:
“(W)hile there is no evidence to suggest that members of racial or ethnic groups are generally subjected to particular forms of torture or ill-treatment
applied uniquely to them in their status as members of these groups, it must be noted that they are
particularly vulnerable to torture in various context
and their status may also affect the consequences of
their ill treatment. It would appear that members of
racial or ethnic groups are disproportionately subjected to torture and other forms of ill-treatment. Indeed, ethnic differences may often contribute to the
process of dehumanisation of the victims, which is
often a necessary condition for torture and ill-treatment to take place.” 19
In its contribution to the World Conference
against Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerance (WCAR), the
United Nations Committee Against Torture stated that:
“Discrimination of any kind can create a climate in
which torture and ill-treatment of the «other» group
subjected to intolerance and discriminatory treatment can more easily be accepted, and that discrimination undermines the achievement of the realization of equality of all persons before the law”. 20
3.1. What has been done so far about police
violence in Patras
Police violence and ill-treatment are not new
phenomena in Patras. They have been also
documented and condemned in the past by
Greek (both local and national) and international non-governmental organizations, as well
as by activist networks. Nevertheless, only few
cases have managed to reach the courts.
12
19 E
/C.N.4/2001/66, 25/01/2001
20 See: http://www.unilu.ch/files/schattenbericht_omct.pdf
The local solidarity group “Kinisi” – Motion for
the defence of refugees’ and migrants’ rights –
has repeatedly condemned police violence
since the group came into existence in October
2007. 21
In early 2008, members of the group filed a lawsuit against the Greek coastguard and police
at the port of Patras, regarding several cases of
migrant’s mistreatment on February. On February 22, 2008 six policemen surrounded and
beat with sticks a group of young Afghan migrants, breaking the arm of Ali Mohamed, a 16
year-old minor. One of the Afghans, 28 year-old
Sotzaat Rezai escaped the police assault only
to be found later on by policemen, who beat
him again with sticks and fractured his thumb.
On February 25, 21 year-old Kader Bahri was
arrested by two coast guards. The two coast guards first escorted the victim out of the Patras
port. Then they beat him up and twice threw
in the sea. On February 26, 20 year-old Morteza
Moranti was chased by three uniformed men
who kicked him in the back. On the same day
four coast guards surrounded two Afghan asylum seekers at the port of Patras. They arrested
16 year-old Ramazan Karemi and pushed him
into the sea and beat his friend, 26-year-old
Mamatela Niazi, causing injuries to his face.
On October 11, 2011 members of the local solidarity group, together with representatives
from Patras’ Afghan Community and five alleged victims of police violence (among them a
12 year old boy) 22 held an official meeting with
the port police, in order to complain about the
general escalation of the violence by state officials in the port of Patras, as well as specific
cases of ill-treatment. In a recent Press Release
“Kinisi” stated: “Regardless of who is the perpetrator each time, unfortunately the victims are
21 Some recent Press Releases of “Kinisi” concerning police
violence in Patras (in Greek):
05.01.12: http://www.kinisipatras.gr/index.php?option=com_
content&view=article&id=78%3A--512012&catid=15%3A-2012&Itemid=8&lang=el
22.12.11: http://www.kinisipatras.gr/index.php?option=com_
content&view=article&id=76%3A--22122011&catid=14%3A2011&Itemid=62&lang=el
13.10.11: http://www.kinisipatras.gr/index.php?option=com_
content&view=article&id=69%3A--13102011&catid=14%3A2011&Itemid=62&lang=el
27.09.11: http://www.kinisipatras.gr/index.php?option=com_
content&view=article&id=68%3A-27092011&catid=14%3A2011&Itemid=62&lang=el
06.04.11: http://www.kinisipatras.gr/index.php?option=com_
content&view=article&id=62%3A--642011&catid=14%3A2011&Itemid=62&lang=el
22 In the end the port authorities did not allow to the
victims to attend the meeting.