the methodological perspectives and analytical tools to gain access to and knowledge from
custodial institutions.
However, scholars in this field, given the widespread nature of the populist anti-immigrant
sentiment, have had to deal with very specific methodological, ethical and conceptual
challenges (Fili, et al., 2018). Border criminology is usually qualitative, theoretically engaged
and interdisciplinary. Its focus on the intersections between criminal justice and migration
control leads to different topics, like justice (Drotbohm and Hasselberg, 2015), citizenship
(Aliverti, 2013), race (Bosworth, Parmar and Vazquez, 2018), ethnicity (Bhui, 2016),
sovereignty (De Genova and Peutz, 2010) and power (Bosworth, 2018). As Katja Aas and
Mary Bosworth (2013) remind us, the central concepts of punishment and society need to
be adjusted and rethought in the context of mass migration. This thesis, and in particular
chapter 1, where I explore issues of positionality and the realities of doing research in a
political environment, is further evidence that researchers in the field need to constantly
reflect upon the impact of their interpersonal, political and institutional contexts within
which their methodological decisions are shaped.
In its predominantly theoretical bent, much of the prison and detention literature draws
on Michel Foucault’s (1991; 2004) writings on governmentality and biopower, and Giorgio
Agamben’s (1998; 2004) ideas of the state of exception and the Camp. This approach,
though, presents a bleak view, with little space for fighting back. While my earlier writings
were influenced by the concept of ‘bare life’, my choice not to engage with it in this thesis,
is not solely motivated by intellectual concerns. The adoption (or not) of particular
concepts reflects our personal and academic biographies. In attempting to dream of a
reconfigured world, where borders (may exist) but do not define us, and detention centres
are obsolete (Davis, 2003), I have looked elsewhere for inspiration.
Abolition: the elephant in detention
While the body of work described above is important in appreciating the textures and
details of custodial institutions, often researchers, including myself, see immigration and
detention as a race to the bottom (Canning, 2021). Immigration detention centres across
the world are opaque places, entangled in emerging assemblages of bordered forms of
penality, with prison-like, overcrowded and unhygienic conditions. Those that live inside
them experience high levels of anxiety, depression and post-traumatic stress disorder, while
27
Επιλογή στοχευμένης παραγράφου3
Σύνδεση με παράγραφο
Σύνδεση με οντότητα
Απενεργοποίηση επισημάνσεων
Προσθήκη στον πίνακα περιεχομένων