1. INTRODUCTION
This report is a follow up to GCR’s 2023
Report on pushback cases titled “At Europe’s Borders: Between Impunity and
Criminalization”.1 The aim of this series
of reports is to contribute to an existing
body of extensive documentation of the
Greek state’s illegal pushbacks practice
and shed light on this systematic state
policy, by providing detailed descriptions of pushωback cases legally represented by GCR before the European
Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) and /
or the Greek Public Prosecutor.
While the GCR’s 2023 Report recounted pushback cases brought before the
ECtHR between March 2022 and October 2022, this report recounts pushback cases in the Evros border region
that occurred in 2023 and brought before the ECtHR between May 2023 and
February 2024. The report also presents essential judicial developments
that occurred in 2023 and the first half
of 2024 on earlier pushback cases, all
legally represented by GCR and filed
with the ECtHR.
The report first presents the latest updates on the situation of human rights at
the EU’s external land and sea borders
as documented by international and
national human rights bodies and institutions and independent authorities,
in line with civil society organizations’
and international media’s reports (see
Chapter 2 below). Within this context,
we share updates on the Deadly Pylos
Shipwreck case and set the broader
context with regards to the treatment
of the newly arrived asylum seekers in
the Evros border region.
Next, an in-depth analysis of the victims’ testimonies on 12 pushback operations in the Evros region throughout
2023 demonstrates that said illegal
practices are continuing as a comprehensive, systematic, and meticulously
planned migration and border policy
of the Greek state, revealing a modus
operandi of the Greek authorities, consistent with numerous credible reports
from UN, European and national institutions, documenting the same pattern:
informal arrest, arbitrary and incommunicado detention, illegal confiscation of
personal belongings, degrading strip
search, violent transfer to the Evros
riverbank and illegal expulsion to Türkiye. Additionally, the recent judicial
developments of three cases regarding pushbacks that occurred between
2013 and 2021, in conjunction with official statistical data on the progress
of investigations into pushback cases
in the country, highlight the systemic
issue of ineffective criminal investigations into pushbacks and rights violations in Greece, that contribute to an
environment of impunity, as the cycle of
ill-treatment of people in need of international protection at the EU external
borders remains unchallenged.
1
GCR’s 2023 Report recounted pushback cases brought before the ECtHR between March 2022
and October 2022: GCR, At Europe’s Borders: Between Impunity and Criminalization, March 2023, available
[in English and Greek] at: https://www.gcr.gr/en/ekdoseis-media/reports/item/2110-at-europe-s-borders-between-impunity-and-criminalization
4
AT EUROPE’S BORDERS: PUSHBACKS CONTINUE AS IMPUNITY PERSISTS