Assessing Vulnerability
The fact of being unaccompanied is a key factor in rendering a child vulnerable. Yet
in practice, Greek police hardly ever establish whether a child is unaccompanied.
Indeed, it appears that the authorities are reluctant to identify children as such. 81
When asked about the presence of unaccompanied children, the chief of Samos
police said, “Usually, children who arrive here are accompanied; they stay with their
families and then they leave together.”82 A representative of the Hellenic coastguard
told Human Rights Watch that out of more than 25,000 persons the coastguard had
apprehended in the past five years “there were no reported cases of unaccompanied
minors.”83
In 2007 and the first half of 2oo8, the Ministry of Interior issued a total of 12,904
orders of deportation to children for illegal entry or presence in the country. The
Ministry, however, was unable to tell Human Rights Watch how many of these orders
were given to unaccompanied children and how many had been given multiple times
to the same persons (see chapters V and VIII for a discussion on detention and
deportation orders).84 This blindness to a whole category of children means that few
are even entering the protection system, inadequate as it is.
There are serious flaws in the way authorities identify vulnerable individuals. Human
Rights Watch interviewed several unaccompanied children who were victims of
armed conflict, violence, or abuse. Some appeared to be victims of trafficking. In no
case did the police correctly identify their vulnerability and special needs, or refer
them to special services (see also chapter VII).85 Indeed, the chief of police in Samos
81
The NGO Pro Asyl found that police in Mitilini, Lesvos Island, deliberately registered unaccompanied children as being
accompanied by strangers. Pro Asyl, “The truth may be bitter but it must be told,” October 2007,
http://www.proasyl.de/fileadmin/proasyl/fm_redakteure/Englisch/Griechenlandbericht_Engl.pdf (accessed September 1,
2008) p. 25, and Papageorgiu and Dimitropoulou, Unaccompanied Minors Study, pp. 42-43.
82
Human Rights Watch interview with Ioannis Kotsampasi, chief of police, Samos, May 30, 2008.
83
Human Rights Watch interview with Konstantinos Gialelis, Hellenic Coast Guard, Intelligence Directorate, Piraeus, June 5,
2008.
84
The Deputy Minister of Interior made these figures public in a response letter to a question by a Member of Parliament on
August 11, 2008. A copy of the letter is on file with Human Rights Watch.
85
An Athens-based service provider for torture victims told us that the majority of patients are referred to them by NGOs and
that the police had made referrals in the past two years. We were furthermore told that state funding for these services ceased
Left to Survive
28
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات