The Silent Humanitarian Crisis in Greece: Devising Strategies to Improve the Situation of Migrants in Greece
workshop report
Access to Basic Human
Rights for All Migrants
panelinput
The Humanitarian Crisis in Context
Nikitas Kanakis, Doctors of the World Greece
The economic crisis has plunged Greece into a social crisis that requires a
humanitarian response, as more people, Greeks and migrants, are struggling
to survive and have become further excluded from the state welfare system.
Migrants have contributed to the development and economy of Greece but once
hit by the economic crisis, they were the first to be forgotten and excluded and
are now being treated as pseudo-citizens and as if they do not exist.
The unyielding austerity measures that are currently in place in Greece have
reduced access to basic human rights both for migrants and Greek citizens
themselves, and have pushed people into destitution with little hope of support
or resolve. While Greek citizens have faced substantial challenges in attending
to basic needs (such as access to food and health care), migrants, particularly
those in an irregular situation, face even greater challenges in accessing such
services and have increasingly also become targets of racist violence, thus
challenging their most fundamental right: the right to life.
There is a worrying increase of incidences of racist violence that are left
unpunished and with no one speaking out or reacting against it. The question
no longer only concerns migration and the right to be or not be in a country, but
raises the issue of intentional acts of cruelty being exerted to deny a person’s
right to live in dignity. The question raised today is whether Greece supports
a society of solidarity as a solution to the crisis, or whether Greece wants to
respond with exclusion. It is not only about the rights of migrants but the right
of society to be democratic.
Doctors of the World remains committed to serving everyone, without
discrimination, a mission it will continue regardless of criticism or threats. We
believe it is our medical and ethical duty to act and respond to the crimes and
violations we witness every day.
We cannot close our eyes and ears to the cries we see every day. We cannot be
neutral to the crimes we see. We have to raise our voice.
Reflecting on the right to health care, Greek authorities have used financial
cutbacks as a means of justifying the denial of the right to healthcare for
migrants. However, regardless of the monetary amount saved, if any2, the
social problems which result, such as social exclusion, fragmentation of society,
disengaged and disempowered members of society, sick patients left in the
streets, etc. have a far more adverse effect on society and social interaction in
the long term. Integration and social cohesion could have far greater economic
returns and social value in the long term.
Doctors of the World will continue to do its work without discrimination in the
hope of catalysing a political and social action to protect and guarantee the
human rights of all persons.
2
6
Research suggests that emergency health care ends up being more costly than prevention and provision of basic health care services to the
whole population without discrimination. See EU Fundamental Rights Agency (FRA), Migrants in an irregular situation: access to healthcare in 10
European Union Member States (2011), pp. 33
7