If arrested, migrants were brought to the Police Directorate, where no information on their
status, their rights or interpretation was provided to them. They were then either let free
or transferred and detained in other police
stations under equally degrading conditions.
Or they were transferred to the Athens Aliens
Police. It seems that shortly after their transfer
to Athens, most of them were immediately released and returned to Patras on foot.
“Pink card’ holders also reported cases of alleged ill-treatment during identity checks or
mass police raids. Some of them have even
expressed their fear of being “targeted” by the
police, because they are “pink card” holders,
and said that asylum seekers are treated worse
than others.
Police raids take place daily 42 in the places where migrants and refugees live, and are often followed by their eviction from these places. During these raids and mass roundups, migrants
claimed that the police destroyed their personal belongings (clothes, blankets, food, mobile
phones and SIM-cards and their documents) or
set fire to them in order to force them to evacuate these places. We have been also told of
police officers who threw tear gas or stones at
migrants in the old factory of Peiraki Patraiki,
in order to force them out.
Police violence and harassment also takes
place in other places, such as the traffic lights
around the port of Patras, where migrants try
to jump on the trucks, or in places where food
is distributed to those in need, by solidarity
groups or members of the church, and even
outside supermarkets, where migrants searching for food in rubbish bins, or while walking to hospitals or to local NGOs.
In some cases reported to us, police officers on
motorcycles have approached migrants from
behind and without any warning or obvious
reason would hit or beat them while still in
motion. In one specific case, a police officer on
a motorcycle collided with a migrant and broke his leg. The migrant was then transferred to
hospital. No investigation of this incident ever
took place.
42 D
uring the research in Patras police raids took place on
a daily level in the abandoned industrial area of Peiraiki
Patraiki and in other provisory places where migrants
and refugees stay and live.
20
A large number of these reported incidents of
ill-treatment by law enforcement officers, take
place in the new Passengers’ Port of Patras. The
victims were migrants intercepted within the
port area, inside the ferries or inside, underneath or close to the trucks. The alleged perpetrators in most of the cases were officers
from the Special Operations Unit of the Hellenic Coast Guard (KEA). Migrants and refugees
referred to them as “commandos”, whose work
includes the detection of “illegal” migrants trying to leave Greece without documentation. In
a few cases, the port police or the private security company personnel operating inside the
Patras port premises, were also cited as perpetrators.
In most cases, the victims told us that even
though they had been immobilized, handcuffed and did not resist arrest, they were ill-treated by the “commandos”. In almost all of the
cases, the victims stated that they were taken
to remote places out of sight, where they were
then beaten. On most occasions, the port authorities did not arrest the migrants or file any
administrative or criminal case against them.
It is obvious, that violence and ill-treatment is generalised, even when there is no resistance from migrants.
Interviewees told us that they have been
beaten with batons and telescopic metallic batons, and punched and kicked in every part of
their bodies, even in the head. In some cases,
they were forced to lie down on the ground
while the perpetrators walk on their backs or
step on their hands.
Due to the serious injuries caused by these beatings, some migrants were rushed to hospital, in some cases bleeding, with broken arms
or legs, unable to walk, or unconscious or in a
coma. Some migrants told us they were in pain
for a long time, in some cases even for months.
We have seen – and in some cases taken photos
of – scars, bruises, broken legs, open wounds
and other injuries. In very few cases have we
seen medical certificates regarding the injuries.
Apart from the physical violence inflicted
on them, we have been also told of different
patterns of ill-treatment, which arouse feelings of fear, anxiety, distress and inferiority
and which made migrants feel humiliated and
worthless. We have been told that the “com-
mandos” often forced migrants to jump into
the freezing sea in winter and remain there for
more than ten minutes. Others described how
they were terrified and hunted by the police
on motorbikes and/or with dogs, which were
even sometimes biting them. One interviewee
described how he was forced on to his hands
and knees and “ridden” like a horse.
At least five victims reported to us that
electroshock weapons had been used against
them, such as electroshock batons and tasers 43.
One of them showed us pictures of the scars
the taser had left behind. Another interviewee
told us that he was threatened with a loaded
gun. In another case, the victim told us that the
offenders took photos of him with their mobile
phones in a humiliating position. Yet another
victim was forced to take off all of his clothes
for an intimate (strip) search, without any reasonable cause or formality - as required - in order to carry out this search. Yet another victim
was forced by a police officer to enter into a
garbage bin, whereupon the lid was closed over
his head.
In all these cases, the victims were also
insulted with words and gestures, directed at
their honour, reputation, family, ethnic origin,
skin colour and religion. Most of the time they
were told to leave Greece and go back home.
All these are clear expressions of racism and
discrimination.
It is more than clear to us, that the ill-treatment
occurring in Patras, has no other purpose than
the one of terrifying and “punishing” these
persons, either because they have attempted
to leave Greece or just because they are staying in that city. The aim is obviously to discourage them from coming. All of the people we
have talked to expressed their fear and terror
of further ill-treatment and felt vulnerable and
unprotected.
Allegations of the ill-treatment of migrants and refugees by law-enforcement officers
in Patras, have been documented at least since
2007 (see chapter 3.1). Nevertheless, these incidents continue to be widespread and even got
worse. The Greek governments’ reluctance to
address this problem is exacerbating the climate of impunity, which fosters further incidents
of ill-treatment. As long as effective actions
aren‘t taken to investigate these allegations
and as long as the perpetrators aren‘t brought
to justice, the climate of impunity will persist.
The reported incidents of ill-treatment by law
enforcement officers, could amount to torture
or other forms of cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment, which are not tolerated under
any circumstances according to the Greek, European and international law. No exception can
be made in the name of “combating illegal migration”.
43 The tasers according to CPT are electrical discharge
weapons (EDW). There are various types of EDW, ranging
from electric shock batons and other hand-held weapons
requiring direct contact with the person who is the
intended target to weapons capable of delivering dartlike projectiles, which administer an electric shock to a
person located at some distance.
On 12.12.2011 the Athens Mixed Jury Court convicted a
retired police officer for two acts of torture with electroshocks using a stun gun on two youth G. Sidiropoulos and
I. Papakostas in Aspropyrgos (Attica) on 14.8.2002. That
was the first and the only case in Greece that a Court
handed a conviction with torture, article 137A par.1 and 2
of the Criminal Code.
Source:
http://www.cpt.coe.int/en/documents/eng-standards.pdf
See also: Periklis Korovesis‘ parliamentary interpellation
to the Ministry of Citizen Protection on the use of tasers
by the Greek police and consequent response.
http://syriza-vyrona.pblogs.gr/2009/01/398367.html
Eleutherotypia (January 22, 2009): “Halt“ of death with
electroshock – What does M26 Tazer cause?
http://www.enet.gr/?i=news.el.article&id=9778
21