may also leads to prolonged detention of asylum applicants. The Administrative Court of Kavala
highlighted in the case of an Iranian national that his will to apply for asylum was not registered due to the
lack of interpretation services and thus he had to be considered as an asylum seeker according to the
law.1221
Overpassing procedures prescribed by national legislation
National legislation provides that newly arrived persons should be initially subjected to reception and
identification procedures prior to any assessment of the possibility to impose detention measures.
However, during 2024, and in particular in the first half of 2024, newly arrived persons arriving in locations
where no RICs/CCACs were in operations (for example Crete, Kalamata etc.) were frequently subject to
automatic detention in mainland PRDCs instead of undergoing Reception and Identification procedures,
contrary to national legislation and despite the fact that as a rule they are persons belonging to vulnerable
groups (e.g. shipwrecks survivors and survivors of dangerous sea journeys).
1.4. Detention without legal basis or de facto detention
Apart from detention of asylum applicants under the Asylum Code and pre-removal detention under L
3386/2005 and L 3907/2011, detention without legal basis in national law or de facto detention measures
are being applied for immigration purposes. These cases include the following:
Detention upon entry in RICs or in the ‘Closed Controlled Access Centres’ (CCAC)
Since mid-2022 persons willing to apply for asylum on the mainland have to present themselves to
Malakasa Reception and Identification Centers (RIC) –for South Greece– or Diavata RIC –for North
Greece– in order to undergo reception and identification procedures and for the full registration of their
asylum application. Similarly, on the islands, newly arrived persons are transferred to Closed Controlled
Access Centers (CCAC) for reception and identification and for the registration of their application (see
sections on The domestic framework: Reception and Identification Centres & Registration of the asylum
application).
In both cases, as prescribed by Article 40 Asylum Code, all persons in mainland RICs or CCAC on the
islands are subject to an up to 25-day restriction of their personal liberty within the premises of the
RIC/CCAC; a measure amounting to de facto detention, applied in a generalised, indiscriminate
manner.1222 Depending on the registration capacity/workload of the Authorities, prior of the Decision
restricting the liberty within the premises of RIC, additional “waiting periods” within the premises of
RICs/CCAC are applied which may also amount to de facto detention. This means that, in practice, the
only option for persons willing to apply for asylum in Greece is to be subjected to a de facto detention
measure. An infringement letter has been sent to the Greek Authorities by the EU Commission on the
ground that this provision leads to blanket and de facto detention of asylum applicants, while in
accordance with EU law, the detention of asylum applicants can only be imposed exceptionally and under
the condition that one of the grounds prescribed in Directive 2013/33/EU is met.1223 Additionally, the
Administrative Court of Athens ruled that the restriction of the personal liberty of an Afghan family within
the premises of the RIC/CCAC was unlawful, since after a period of more than two weeks their application
for asylum was not registered.1224
Other forms of de facto detention such as detention pending transfer to RICs, de facto detention of those
arrived in Athens Airport transit zone and detention in the case of alleged pushbacks continued to occur
during 2024 according to information received by GCR. In this regard, in the landmark judgement of the
European Court of Human Rights in A.R.E. v Greece,1225 supported by GCR, the Court additionally found
a violation of Article 5 ECHR due to the informal and arbitrary de facto detention of the Applicant prior of
the pushback thought out the Evros river.
1221
Administrative Court of Kavala, Decision 824/2024.
Inter alia also see Joint Civil Society Statement, Not Again in 2024: Call for upholding human rights in the
Samos Closed Control Access Centre, January 2024, available at: https://tinyurl.com/4x79wrs4, p. 2.
1223
European Commission, January Infringements package: key decisions, 26 January 2023, available at:
https://bit.ly/45tH02U.
1224 Administrative Court of Athens, Decision 2200/2024.
1225
For more information, see Access to the territory and pushbacks.
1222
222
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents