the conditions of detention of third country nationals in
the Athens airport detention centre violated the
prohibition on inhuman or degrading treatment in Article
3 ECHR21.
The centre was designed to provide short-term
housing prior to transfer to another detention facility in
Athens. In practice, however, both economic immigrants
and asylum seekers are routinely held in the centre for
more than 90 days. The facility itself is divided into two
parts: one for those detained on a ‘criminal’ basis, that is
those who attempted to leave Greece with fake
documents, and another for women, minors and the
small number of people who arrive in Greece by plane.
Women, minors and arrivals are allowed relative
freedom of movement and only a few stay for more than
one month. However, the men
housed in the main section are
huddled together in spaces
designed as single-occupancy cells
(each 9 square metres) behind iron
doors with very little natural light
and no access to an exercise yard.
Their only physical movement is
limited to going to the toilet for a
few minutes in the morning and
the evening. At all other times
they are locked inside their cells
with nothing to do. At times even
this ‘trip’ to the toilet is not
allowed
due
to
severe
overcrowding or staff inaction. As
detention officers put it: ‘We are
not their servants here. They
cannot go to the toilet whenever
they want. They are too many, so we will take them only
when we can’22.
At the time of writing, 67 people are detained in
this way in nine single-bed cells, though the number has
reached a high point of 120 detainees. These men have
to sleep on mattresses or blankets placed directly on the
floor. When it is crowded like this, the men cannot all
can lie down and sleep at the same time. Other rules
restrain them: they are not allowed to smoke more than
three cigarettes, they are not given cutlery for ‘security’
reasons and conditions of hygiene are never properly
observed leading to the transmission of contagious
diseases. The effect of absolute control is not lost on the
male detainees: ‘we are buried alive here. This is like a
mass grave’ … ‘but we are not animals, we are humans
and we have human rights, no?’
In 2012 Medical Intervention wrote a report,
addressed to all the relevant Ministries and officials, to
register the main deficiencies of the airport detention
area. Although the officials at the airport centre initially
responded merely by threatening lawsuits for slander, the
leakage of the report in the media appears to have
energized the management and staff to create better
conditions for the detainees. During the summer, a large
number of detainees were released, the frequency of
access to toilet was increased, plastic cutlery was offered
with every meal and generally officers were more
receptive to our suggestions.23 Such changes, though
welcome, do little to address the
basic problems of this facility that,
in January 2012, was held by the
CPT (2012) to contravene basic
standards of decency and
humanity.
Their only physical
movement is limited
to going to the toilet
for a few minutes in
the morning and the
evening. At all other
times they are locked
inside their cells with
nothing to do.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
Trapped in Greece
Greece will soon detain a
much
larger
number
of
immigrants than its current
prison population of 12,000
people 24. Operation ‘Xenios
Zeus’, launched in August, 2012
by Prime Minister Antonis
Samaras, aims to restore human
dignity to immigrants at the
same time as it sets out plans to
arrest all undocumented migrants in Greece,
indefinitely detain them in web of remote centres
located in buildings pressed into service for this
reason, before eventually deporting them. According
to police sources they have so far arrested 10,000
people and detained more than 4,000 25. The
government has also announced its intention to build
30 new detention centres by 2014 to hold 30,000
immigrants. The multi-million programme, funded by
the European Union, foresees the creation of ‘closed
hospitality centres’ on unused military sites to fight
inner-city crime, deter economic immigrants and
create local jobs26.
M.S.S. v Belgium and Greece, op cit, para. 231-234; R.U. v Greece, ECtHR , Application No.2237/08 of June 7, 2011, para. 63-64; S.D. v
Greece, ECtHR , Application No. 53541/07 of June 11, 2009, para. 49-54.
Detainees claim that they are allowed to go to the toilet for a maximum 3 times a day. Many times they urinate in plastic bottles or against
the doors.
They have now allowed us to offer them books and detainees can buy food from the canteen at the airport as meal portions are very
small.
The number of migrant detainees cannot be found in any official police statistics; however, based on rough estimates this number is now
around 10.000.
See, http://euobserver.com/justice/117178
The first of such centres built on the outskirts of Athens will soon hold 2.000 immigrants.
Issue 205
Prison Service Journal
37
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents