Unwanted, Unnoticed: an audit of 160 asylum and immigration-related deaths in Europe
migrants died in a fire caused by a fallen candle
in a squat in Pantin, Paris. The migrants, most
of whom were Tunisian, were destitute and
lived in the squat with other undocumented
migrants. The lawyer of four of the families
of those who died requested provisional residency permits for seventeen survivors of the
fire, but by the end of 2013, only two of the
seventeen had received permits. An Egyptian
migrant was given an eighteen-month prison
sentence for accidentally causing the fire.
The French NGO, the League for Human
Rights, has said that the incident highlights
the urgent need for safe accommodation for
undocumented migrants.26
• Ismael (20), 22/12/2011
An Ethiopian asylum seeker, Ismael was
found dead at the bottom of a bridge in the
centre of Calais. Ismael was well-known in
migrant and activist circles in Calais, and his
friends disagree with the Boulogne-sur-Mer
public prosecutor’s theory that he committed suicide, stating that the drop was not
of itself enough to kill him. An inquest and
autopsy were refused.27
• Unidentified man (27), 19/09/2013
A Bosnian asylum seeker was found dead in
his tent in a makeshift camp in a disused
parking lot in Metz. It is believed that the
man was in poor health and that he died
of natural causes. The French charity, the
Moselle Collective for the Struggle Against
Poverty, states that prior to his death,
they had made complaints about the poor
conditions of those living in the camp, to
no avail. As a consequence of his death, a
court in Strasbourg has ordered the demolition of the camp and the re-housing of
the other asylum seekers. The Collective is
lobbying for the upholding of the dignity
of asylum seekers and for urgent liveable
accommodation.28
• Dorel Iosif Floarea (42), 29/07/2014
A Romanian migrant, Floarea died in
Montgeron, Essonne, after being apprehended by police and shot in the stomach with
live ammunition, as well as by a ‘flash-ball’
gun (which fires rubber bullets). Floarea, his
brother and a friend were drinking near a
building squatted by minority ethnic groups
when the police arrived and told them to stop
drinking. One policeman allegedly grabbed
Floarea’s bottle, emptied its contents and
threw it in the bin. Another officer claimed
that he felt threatened by Floarea, tried to
move away from him and fell. A third policeman then shot Floarea with a ‘flash-ball’,
and the policeman on the ground shot him
in the thorax. Floarea died of his injuries.
An investigation has been opened.29
• Abdelhak Goradia (51), 21/08/2014
An Algerian undocumented migrant, Goradia
died after being driven to the airport by
police for deportation. He had received a
deportation notice nine days earlier, after
being convicted of theft, fraud and aggravated assault on his brother. Despite his
lawyer reminding the police several times
that the deportation could not go ahead
because legal proceedings were ongoing,
Goradia was allegedly handcuffed, removed
from his cell and driven to the airport. The
police initially stated that Goradia died from
a ‘sudden heart attack’, but the autopsy
found that he died from asphyxiation and
vomiting. Investigations have begun into an
‘involuntary homicide’ case.30
GERMANY
SNAPSHOT: In September 2014, footage
emerged from Germany showing guards
from one of the main operators of asylum
reception facilities, European Homecare,
abusing asylum seekers, forcing them
to lie down on mattresses covered in
vomit and standing with a boot on their
neck. Germany’s use of prisons to detain
migrants and asylum seekers has been
condemned by the European Court of
Justice, and hunger strikes and protests
at detention conditions and treatment are
common – as are protests against the law
of compulsory residence.31
IRR | European Research Progamme Briefing No. 10
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents