this occurred
public protestsagainst the detentionof migrants.Not surprisingly,
in responseto pressurefromboth outside and inside of the detentioncentre.
Gender constructionscan serve as means to differently
designate groups of
and
are
as
unauthorized
or
indeed
illegal
employed by states and
migrants
internationalagencies to better controlmigrants'mobility.Recentlyin the US,
publiccriticismof the brutalseparation of mothersfromtheirchildren,following
authorities,has led to the temporaryrelease of
workplaceraids by immigration
women from detention. This policy aimed to allow women to care for their
children (providing the children themselves were US citizens) until their
deportation,withoutcalling intoquestion the overall logic of the migrationraids
and the eventual deportationorders (Luibhéid and Anderson,2008: 2). For the
women in Lesvos the mechanism of preferentialliberation seems to serve a
similarpurpose: on the one hand it reproducesthe assumptionthat womenare
the primarycaregiversby transferring
them into 'a more humane centre' where
can
better
their
role
as
mothers;on the other,this policyhelps
accomplish
they
the state to legitimizeits violentpractices of detentionand removal,improveits
public image and defend itself against humanitariancriticism.
Similarto the way in whichthe state and internationallegislation created the
figure of the 'victim of trafficking'as a female victim of sex trafficking
(Andrijasevic,2008a), this example of 'detentionmanagement'that favoursthe
release of 'womenand children'over men, can be understoodas a contradictory
expressionof the uneasiness of the state to reconcileits liberal and democratic
face withthe intrinsicinjusticeof immigration
controls(Luibhéidand Anderson,
2008). The figure of the powerless migrantwoman, depicted as the more
vulnerable subject deserving the exceptional treatment of (still temporary)
release, epitomizes the way in whichsexualityand gender are integralto the
differentiatingdevices through which illegality is produced (Luibhéid and
Anderson,2008: 2). In this regard, there is agreement in both academic and
policy debates that the tighteningof border controls ends up reducingthe
possibilitiesforpeople to migratelegallyintothe 6U, whereas illegalitybecomes
the usual way to describe currentpatterns of internationalmigrationand to
stigmatizemigrants(Andrijasevic,2006: 123).
The case of 'gentler detention' expressed in the selection of women indeed
complicates the pictureof a simple restrictivepattern in migrationcontrolsin
Europeand beyond,pointingto a situation in whichthe logic of detentionand
border policing sometimes allow for 'spaces of circulation' and mobilityfor
migrants,ratherthan puttingthem in a definiteconditionof immobility.With
this regardthe use of these particular'gender techniques' throughwhichthese
exceptions are constituted can be better understood within the broader
framework
of Greekpolicyand the £U regimeof migrationmanagement.
Gabrieiia Alberti fe m i η i st
This content downloaded from 163.1.255.60 on Fri, 10 Apr 2015 17:57:53 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
revi ew
94
2010
141