Psychological harm
In interpreting Article 7, the Human Rights
Committee has recognised that “The prohibition in
Article 7 relates not only to acts that cause physical
pain but also to acts that cause mental suffering
to the victim.”51 In addition, Article 3 of the ECHR
incorporates both physical and mental suffering,
and where:
‘treatment humiliates or debases an individual,
showing a lack of respect for, or diminishing his
or her human dignity, or arouses feelings of fear,
anguish or inferiority capable of breaking an
individual’s moral and physical resistance, it may
be characterised as degrading and also falls within
the prohibition of Article 3’.52
BVMN has identified that at least 45% of
testimonies report psychological harm, and
respondents consistently expressed fear or severe
mental ill-health as a result of: the poor conditions
of detention, lack of information provided to
detainees regarding their detention decisions
leaving them in an information void, lack of
access to recreational activities and the general
impacts of being deprived of liberty, as well as
their treatment by detention staff, who reportedly
employed intimidation and humiliation tactics,
degrading use of language, threats of physical
violence or total neglect.
Psychological torment, humiliation
and self harm
Due to severe neglect, humiliation and
psychological deterioration of detainees particularly for those who are held in PRDCs for
extended periods of time - several respondents
referenced the practice of self-harm, sometimes as
an attempt to receive medical attention. As a result
of medical care not being sufficiently provided in
detention - unless in the case of an emergency
or for critical cases - respondents explained that
it was not uncommon for people to worsen their
injuries or deliberately harm themselves to access
a hospital. Suicide has also been reported across
detention centres in Greece for many years.53
Respondent 20, Morocco. Detained in Paranesti
PRDC.
Some people just cut their bodies but they don’t
do anything to them. So, they don’t support them
with mental issues or psychological issues, all these
things.
Respondent 24, Algeria. Detained in Paranesti
PRDC.
They treat everyone inside the same. In the mental
issue or health issue. Only in the case someone beat
himself, to cut his body with a knife or something
like that. But I am old, I am 37 and I dont want to cut
myself like that or something. So they respond only
in this case, when someone cut/beat himself.
Respondent 22, Egypt. Detained in Corinth PRDC.
It must be really tough condition in order for them
to take it seriously. There is a doctor but the highest
thing he gonna do he will give me something to
calm you. So people beat themselves in order to
be taken to the hospital. So probably they damage
themselves. So that’s why they take them to the
hospital.
Respondent 5, Pakistan. Detained in Amygdaleza
PRDC.
I’m very tense and feeling so much depressed
because you know, I was there since many months
... I was very depressed to be there. Cause I wanted
to have ... freedom
Respondent 20, Morocco. Detained in Paranesti
PRDC.
Because most of these people were like using pills
and drugs, so they need these things inside, so…
and the pressure that they are in, all this stress…
after they start to beat themselves. [And is the
police- they are not doing anything about this they
are just letting this– ?] Watching.
Respondent 11, Iraq. Detained in Amygdaleza
PRDC.
Like you cannot enter the toilet, and be comfortable
doing what you want to do. For example, when you
enter the cops say you have one minute, 59, 58 and
as sure as you’re one minute finished, even if you
didn’t finish what you are doing, he opens the door
and he takes you out from the toilet. This toilet can
not, it’s outside from the room in the jail, it’s the jail
toilet and the jail only open 3 times, 9 o’clock in
the morning, 1 o’clock afternoon and at 12 o’clock
at night and you can not, if you ask the police in
another time in order to go to the toilet and to do
your things, he say ‘no, do it on yourself’.
The general treatment of people in detention
reportedly contributed extensively to mental ill
health. Respondents expressed their difficulties
sleeping, the legal limbo and lack of understanding
regarding their future, the lack of access to
psychological care and unhygienic conditions as
strong contributing factors to their psychological
suffering. This, as well as the behaviour and
treatment of detention staff, resulted in reports
of severe mental ill health. Some testimonies
specifically detailed incidents of manipulative
15
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents