work as a hinge, linking resistance to a discussion about solidarity, abolition and imagining
a radical future in the epilogue.
Animalisation of immigration
The mass breach of human rights inside detention centres in Greece ‘operates in tandem
with, and is lubricated by, stigmatizing representational practices which involve the
extreme dehumanization of people’ (Tyler, 2020, p. 124). Women in particular were
perceived through a racialised prism as morally and intellectually distinct from and inferior
to citizens (Angel-Ajani 2003; Brennan 2004; Jiwani 2005; Kapur 2005). For example,
Xenia, a detention officer at the Petrou Ralli detention centre tried to explain to me why
Iraqi women do not love their babies. ‘Iraqis have a certain mentality, that women have to be
animals. I’m not saying this to offend them but this is their way of thinking because of their religion, their
culture, as a country, as a people.’ (Interview, Petrou Ralli detention centre, 2011). Detention
officers overwhelmingly viewed women as the racialised embodiment of failing cultures,
employing dogmatic claims about their naivety and their criminal, sexually deviant and
subhuman nature (Angel-Ajani 2003). Maria, an outspoken detention officer, tried to
explain ‘Nigerians suffer a lot. That’s why sometimes they are like animals in a cage. Asian women are
very shy and not very provocative. But Nigerians and Dominicans are very hard women because their
journeys and their lives have been hard too.’ (Interview, Petrou Ralli detention centre, 2011)
What the officers’ testimonies make very clear is that women who irregularly cross borders
are doubly stigmatised, first for their contravention of gender-based expectations and
second, for their breach of the border. Black feminist thought has been instrumental in
problematising the strong black woman ideology and the perception that black women
lack access to femininity (Hartman, 2019; Spillers, 1983). The notion of hegemonic
femininity (Collins, 2004) assumes the superiority of white women by devaluing other
femininities that fall short of meeting the hegemonic standards. As Sandra Gilman claims
in her book ‘Black Bodies, White Bodies’ the sexuality of black women became metonymic
for deviant sexuality in general. A statement by the director of the Petrou Ralli detention
centre highlights the intersection between race and gender as it applies to detained black
women in detention. ‘Nigerians create more problems; they are more dynamic. We try not to put them
all together in the same cells. They are into voodoo and stuff and you can’t communicate with them.
Moreover, they have a different mentality, a street mentality. They come here and become prostitutes and
they become harder than other women. Basically, they are men.’ (Interview, Petrou Ralli detention
centre, 2011). Bosworth, Pickering and I (2018) have argued elsewhere that ‘such
179
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents