all day, despite provisions for an outdoor area. Human Rights Watch (2008) met an Iraqi
Kurd, who had been detained there for three months and had only been outside for 12
hours in total. New arrivals were not provided with clean sheets and blankets and much of
the bedding was dirty. Again, here access to toilets at night was problematic, leaving
detainees with no choice but to urinate in bottles or defecate in plastic bags. Reports from
that period indicate dirty cells infested with cockroaches and a lack of personal care
products and clean blankets, night-time access to the toilet, opportunities for physical
exercise, and access to an outdoor courtyard in most police facilities even when the
facilities had one (Amnesty International, 2010a; CPT, 2008; Human Rights Watch, 2008).
Even before the centre was inaugurated, the CPT had expressed its concerns about its
resemblance to a large police station with a carceral environment. Petrou Ralli, the
independent authority claimed, was a missed opportunity to conform to EU standards
(CPT, 2006).
When questioned, restrictions on the movement of detained migrants had been attributed
to low staff numbers. This is not far from the truth. For example, at one point in 2009
Filakio and Pagani centres had only six officers on duty for 201 and 548 detainees
respectively (CPT, 2010). However, this is not the sole reason. Staff assigned to detention
centres at the borders were not especially trained, nor did they want to assume this role.
What is more, in the event of an escape or serious incident, they would be faced with
severe disciplinary punishments or unemployment. As opposed to police officers, who
could be suspended or dismissed from service, border guards were fired. Therefore, the
direction of increased control and enforcing a warehousing policy is not unanticipated; in
fact, it may have been forthcoming.
Whitewashing violence
The above sheds light on one of the main features of the detention system; the scale of the
problem of ill-treatment of persons deprived of their liberty by law enforcement officials.
Ill-treatment was allegedly often allowed to settle order during fights between different
nationalities and was defiantly underestimated to a few harmless slaps. As the Head of the
Coast Guard Police at Piraeus port admitted to a CPT delegation, he would not tolerate
severe ill-treatment but consented to slaps (CPT, 2002, p. 13). Unfortunately, there are
overwhelming indications that violence by the police did not stop there but instead was
routine, systematic and cloaked in a climate of impunity. Over the number of years that
84
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents