Coping with a fundamental rights emergency – The situation of people crossing the Greek border in an irregular manner
summarised by the European Court of Human Rights, these reports “describe a similar situation
to varying degrees of gravity: overcrowding, dirt, lack of space, lack of ventilation, little or no
possibility of taking a walk, no place to relax, insufficient mattresses, dirty mattresses, no free
access to toilets, inadequate sanitary facilities, no privacy, limited access to care […] [as well as
complaints] of insults, particularly racist insults, proffered by staff and the use of physical
violence by guards.”34
The table below provides a snapshot of the situation found by the FRA in these facilities, either
based on direct on‐site observations by the FRA during the mission or obtained from interviews
and further research. All facilities are seriously overcrowded, making it difficult to ensure
separation by sex as well as separation of children from unrelated adults. Nor is it possible to
separate persons kept in temporary detention, from those who have already obtained a removal
decision and are held beyond three days.
Table 1: Overview of detention facilities in Evros region
Separation
of sexes
(except
families)
Separation
of unac‐
companied
minors
yes
no
no
no
1
One cell, approx.
110m²
during FRA
visit only
men were
held
no
7
Women cell approx.
40 m2 and other 6
cells approx. 100 m2
each
no
no
Capacity
(persons)
Detained
during FRA
visit
(persons)
No of
cells
Feres
30
140 ‐ 150
3
Tychero
45
140 ‐ 150
2
Facility
Soufli
Fylakio
38
374
140 ‐ 150
Approx. 450
2
Space in m
One cell of 48m², one
of 30m² and one of
approx. 40m²
Two cells of 35m²
(CPT, 2005)
Source: FRA
The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or
Punishment recommends 4m² of space per detainee in multi‐occupancy accommodation.35
The Hellenic Federation of Border Guards on 22 January 2011 protested on its website36 about
the conditions of detention: “The conditions of detention, but also the conditions of work in all
reception and detention centres are unacceptable. The detention facilities at the border region
are not suitable for long term stay in detention. The conditions are dangerous both for the
irregular migrants detained, as well as for the staff, who stay there for several months. An
immediate solution must be found, so that a large number of border guards currently engaged
34 ECtHR, M.S.S. v. Belgium and Greece, No. 30696/09, 21 January 2011, para. 162.
35 CPT, Report to the government of Greece on the visit to Greece carried out by the European Committee for the Prevention of
Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT) from 17 to 29 September 2009, 2010, p. 38.
36 Available (in Greek) at: www.posyfy.gr.
26