48
Europe and Central Asia
Summary of Amnesty International’s Concerns in the Region, January – June 2007
de la detention), who authorized his
detention for a further 15 days, and
informed
him
that
he
was
being
investigated by the French police on
suspicion of providing logistical support to a
network which assists individuals to travel
to Iraq to take part in the armed conflict
there – an allegation which he denied.
When he discovered the nature of the
suspicions against him he made a claim for
asylum, on 6 May. On 7 May he was taken
to the regional administrative detention
centre (centre de rétention administrative,
CRA) at Mesnil-Amelot, to be detained while
his asylum claim was processed.
On 10 May Houssine Tarkhani was taken
from the CRA by officers from the French
intelligence services (Direction de la
Surveillance du Territoire, DST), to be
questioned by a judge in relation to
suspected terrorism-related activities. He
was questioned in particular about his
relationship with Mohamed Msahel, a
Tunisian national currently imprisoned in
Morocco on terrorism charges, with whom
Houssine Tarkhani had, on his account,
become acquainted when they attended the
same mosque in Milan. At no stage was
Houssine Tarkhani charged with any
terrorism-related criminal offence.
On 11 May Houssine Tarkhani was returned
to the CRA at Mesnil-Amelot. On 15 May he
was interviewed by officials from OFPRA.
On 25 May he was told that his asylum
application, which had been assessed under
the accelerated procedure (procédure
prioritaire), had been rejected. An appeal
against this decision was lodged with the
CRR. Nonetheless he was, on 3 June,
forcibly returned to Tunisia.
AI has since learnt that Houssine Tarkhani
was, as he feared, detained by officers of
the Tunisian state security (Sûreté de l’Etat)
on his arrival in Tunisia. According to
information available to the organization he
was, on arrest, taken to the State Security
Department of the Ministry of Interior in
Tunis, where he was reportedly tortured
and threatened with death. He was then
held in incommunicado detention for a
period of nine days – longer than is
Amnesty International
permitted by Tunisian law – without being
allowed to contact his family. He has
reportedly now been charged with a
number of broadly-defined offences under
Tunisian counter-terrorism legislation.
AI is concerned that Houssine Tarkhani was
returned to Tunisia before the CRR was able
to determine an appeal which he had made
against the decision to refuse his claim for
asylum in France. AI further notes that,
following its decision in the recent case of
Ferdi Aydin, the CRR appears to regard any
appeal which is outstanding at the moment
when a person is forcibly returned, as
Houssine Tarkhani was, to be without merit,
as long as the person is not outside his/her
country of origin.
The case of Adel Tebourski: update to AI
Index: EUR 21/006/2006
On 11 May, the UN Committee against
Torture (CAT) issued a decision on the case
of Adel Tebourski, who was forcibly
returned from France to Tunisia in August
2006, having been stripped of his dual
French-Tunisian
nationality.
AI
had
previously urged the government not to
return Adel Tebourski due to the possible
risks of ill-treatment (AI Index: EUR
21/006/2006).
Adel Tebourski was returned to Tunisia
before his appeal against the refusal of his
claim for asylum in France had been heard,
and despite a request from the CAT itself
for France to suspend his expulsion while
the Committee examined his case. In the
light of these facts the CAT found that
France had not acted in good faith when it
expelled Adel Tebourski, and that his
expulsion constituted a violation of Articles
3 and 22 of the Convention Against Torture
– that is, respectively, the obligation of
non-refoulement and the obligation on
states who have recognized a right of
individual complaint to the CAT to respect
that right. The CAT has invited France to
make submissions to the Committee on
how it plans to make reparation for this
violation.
AI Index: EUR 01/010/2007
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents