7. Health
42
Given the precarious conditions, as regards hygiene and
safety, within the facilities, and the non-prevention of
disease transmission, both detainees and employees are at
high risk of becoming sick. »I was sleeping for two months
among two people who had Hepatitis. Now they are released.«133
7.3 Insufficient number of specialised
medical staff, inadequate medical
infrastructure, insufficient medication and lack of co-ordination on
the part of the authorities
There is not enough medical staff. The provided medical
staff can neither adequately meet the needs of basic
healthcare examination for all detainees, nor does it suffice
for securing a proper medication. The latter entails tremendous health risks for detainees who depend on their medication, e.g. when they had severe traumatic experiences
and are in need of psycho-pharmacy, or if they have undergone operation or suffer from serious congenital heart
defects. The lack of medical staff particularly for night shifts
and weekends further curtails detainees’ access to doctors
and proper medical treatment. The distribution of medicines during night is assigned to the guards, who are not
trained for carrying out this task. Furthermore, regional
hospitals are unable to examine the high number of newcomers. The medical staff is not trained in migration issues,
and they do not know how to deal with victims of torture,
violence or rape.
There are not enough interpreters. The lack of interpreters in detention centres and in hospitals makes medical
screening, examination and treatment impossible. Doctors,
psychologists and nurses cannot treat detainees adequately, lacking medical equipment, medication and proper
examination rooms.
The management and co-ordination of detainees’ medical
treatment is dysfunctional. In scheduling the examination
of a patient, doctors depend on the police who have a different assignment and therefore different priorities. Means
of transport and guards to accompany hospital transfers
are generally insufficient. As borderguard officers told us in
various occasions, for the transportation of a detainee to
hospital, one police car and two police officers are needed.
Another problem in co-ordination is the transfer or release
of detainees without informing neither the treating doctor
nor the patient. The patient leaves the detention centre
without his/her medical files, without his/her medication
and without referral for further therapy or treatment.
A medical follow-up is impossible.
7.4. Access to and communication
with doctors
Access to health care (medical and psychological treatment) is not always guaranteed, and sometimes guards
arbitrarily discourage the detainees from calling the
medical staff or refuse to refer them to the staff. »I had
been asking for a doctor for many days. I had a bad cold. He
never came, but one day the police took me out and beat
me so I didn’t ask for the doctor again!«135 »You can call for
a doctor 100 times if you want them to react even once!«136
»Once a man fainted inside the cell. We were afraid he
would die. We called the officers, but they did not react.«137
A minor told us: »If somebody needs a doctor, we need to
make a lot of noise and shout. The sick person has to be
lying on the floor, unconscious, for them to take you seriously.«138
Detainees who were ill-treated by the police, told us that
they were not allowed to see the doctor.
Detention facilities do neither offer appropriate examination rooms, nor isolation room for cases of suspectedly contagious diseases. »The doctor gives us pills of four different
colors to treat our sickness. None of them help«.134 During
our missions, we saw doctors examining detainees through
the bars (Feres, October 2011), in inappropriate examination rooms (i.e Tychero) or in places lacking privacy (Feres,
Fylakio).
Detainees systematically complained to the mission’s
team about difficulties in communication, resulting in
inadequate medical care. During the team’s missions, the
doctors (except for the MSF mission) were working even
without any interpreter or with few. The absence of external and professional interpreters compromises the quality
of the delivered health care, as well as the patient’s confidence, especially in cases where other detained migrants
are used as interpreters. Detainees complained to us that,
even when there was a psychologist, they did not want to
speak with him/her, because there was no interpreter and
133 A.F. from Iran; December 18, 2010 – Feres
134 S.Q. from Iran; October 13, 2011 – Ferres
135 D.F. from Turkey; December 19, 2010 – Soufli
136 B.M. from Iran; December 19, 2010 – Soufli
137 F.S. from Iran; December 20, 2010 – Fylakio
138 A.T.M. from Afghanistan; October 11, 2011 – Fylakio
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents