- 53 88.
In the course of the 2015 visit, the delegation examined a number of deaths in prison and
found that in several cases the deaths might have been avoided if proper medical care and
management processes were in place. Reference is made to two specific cases as an illustration:
i)
CC, a heroin user, was remanded to Korydallos Men’s Prison in October 2014 and on
4 April 2015 his medical record noted that he was transferred to Korydallos Prison Hospital
in a “semi-comatose condition after reported using substances. Is on methadone. Intravenous
drug user. Narcan injection and sodium chloride infusion; referred to general hospital for
further treatment and monitoring.” He returned from Nikaia Hospital at 22h15 that same day
after treatment. At 8h35 the next morning he was found to be not breathing and pronounced
dead, supposedly from an overdose of opiates.
The CPT’s delegation is concerned that the discharge letter from Nikaia Hospital does not
provide any information as to how the patient was assessed or treated. Further, there is no
record of the patient being assessed by medical staff upon his return to the prison hospital.
Good practice would normally entail monitoring a person who had suffered an overdose of
opiates to ensure the continued effects of opiate intoxication were not apparent, especially as
opiate intoxication causes respiratory depression. Further, while Nalaxon (“Narcan”) is an
antidote to opiates, it is short acting and often further injections are required until the effects
of the opiate toxicity have worn off.
Moreover, it appears from the post-mortem that the patient was suffering from bronchiopneumonia and a pulmonary oedema (fluid in the lungs), which combined with opiate
intoxication could cause respiratory depression. The chest infection and pulmonary oedema
would not have developed suddenly and should have been diagnosed at Nikaia Hospital. In
sum, an appropriate examination at Nikaia Hospital and proper monitoring following
discharge back to the prison hospital might well have prevented this patient’s death.
ii)
YA was admitted to Nafplio Prison on 7 December 2011 and died on 4 March 2013. The
autopsy report records the cause of death as being tuberculosis of the lungs and liver. In the
12 months prior to his death he had seen the prison doctor on numerous occasions
complaining of abdominal pain, fatigue and loss of weight, and the three blood tests taken (7
July, 3 and 24 October 2012) each showed that his inflammation/infection was getting worse
as was his anaemia. Regrettably, the blood tests taken at Argos Hospital on 24 October,
where he stayed for five days, made no reference to the previous blood tests. A simple chest
x-ray, routine for anyone complaining of weight loss, would have revealed the tuberculosis.
The prison doctor never weighed the person despite noting weight loss in the medical record
on several occasions. The result was that this man suffered a painful and lingering death, as
witnessed by fellow inmates, when such an outcome was avoidable.
The CPT considers that every death of a prisoner should be the subject of an effective
investigation to ascertain, inter alia, the cause of death, the facts leading up to the death, including
any contributing factors, and whether the death might have been prevented, and to establish whether
there has been any negligence warranting disciplinary or criminal proceedings. Such inquiries are
necessary in order to identify possible means to improve the system of prevention in place as well
as to provide the relatives of the deceased person(s) with relevant information concerning the
circumstances of the death.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents