The impact of detention
People will get crazy in here. We have not killed anybody. We
have not robbed anybody. Why are we kept in prison? I have
been here for 10 days and I find life going backwards. I want
my life to go forward. Here the only thing I can do is think
and sleep. I do not want to think of my life. It upsets me and
I might hurt myself or others. If I have to stay in here much
longer I will do something bad to myself.
Afghan adolescent, 16 years old
Being detained was the single most important cause of stress
and frustration for the majority of the migrants. Detention
came as a shock to most them, as they had totally different
expectations about their arrival in Europe and found it very
difficult to cope with their time in detention. Being restricted
in often overcrowded cells, with no or very limited time
outside and no private space at all contributed to their
psychological distress.
Research has demonstrated that “the experience of detention
is traumatic, regardless of the conditions.”51 Detention can
induce fear, isolation, and hopelessness. Different stressors
associated with detention (environmental, procedural, legal)
may contribute to undermine the mental health of detainees,
particularly those who have already suffered past trauma.52
Detention was the main problem for over one third (37%)
of MSF patients. The unacceptable conditions of detention,
the unknown length of detention and being treated like
criminals, were some of the issues migrants raised during first
consultations.
Our patients used one or more of the following terms to
describe their feelings while in detention: they felt “Insecure,”
“in constant worry,” “afraid of police,” “anxious about the
future,” “stressed,” “sad,” “lonely,” “depressed,” “desperate,”
“angry towards authorities for being treated like animals,”
“worthless for failing their families,” “guilty for being
incarcerated.”
The following accounts illustrate the feelings of MSF patients:
I have never been in detention before. I feel very insecure and
frightened. I am very upset. I would like to talk to a lawyer.
Palestinian man, in his early twenties
I am afraid of the police. They talk badly to us. I don’t know
what to do. I don’t have shoes. My clothes are damaged
because my journey was terrible. And I am afraid to ask
anything from the police.
Georgian woman, in her forties
I cannot stand to stay for three months inside here. I am
broken and afraid.
Afghan man, in his early twenties
The unpredictable nature of detention and especially the fear
of deportation was the main concern for 7% of the migrants
who sought the assistance of MSF psychologists. As many
21
of them come from unstable and war torn countries like
Afghanistan, Iraq, the possible threat of deportation to their
country of origin can be life-threatening.
I cannot be deported. I face a death sentence in my country. I
have been in prison for many months. I was tortured. I cannot
stop worrying about being deported. I do not have a problem
being in here. I have been through much worse. I am only
afraid to be deported.
Iranian man, in his early twenties
The context of detention poses special challenges for
migrants with a chronic medical condition, disability or
mental health problem. Patients who were on treatment for
a medical condition in their country of origin were concerned
about not having their medication and/or adequate medical
care. Migrants with physical disabilities had difficulties in
their daily functioning in the detention setting. Such issues
were discussed by 14% of patients in individual counselling
sessions.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents