As the commander in Tychero detention center explained, nationality determinations are a
decisive factor affecting the duration of detention in these facilities because they also
determine whom it will be possible to deport:
Keeping people depends on nationality. If they are nationals of a country
neighboring Turkey, we apply for readmission. That can take up to six
months. To nationals of other countries we give papers that tell them they
have to leave the country within 30 days—after two or three days when the
public prosecutor decides that they will not press charges.121
Because certain nationalities cannot be deported, some undocumented migrants claim to
be members of these groups. Frontex’s nationality-determination screenings are meant to
address this phenomenon.122
Although these screenings are not intended to identify international protection needs, in
reality they are usually the most substantive interviews detainees have before being
deported. Given the formidable barriers to lodging asylum claims in Greece (particularly in
the Evros region),123 if these interviews fail to facilitate access to the asylum process, they
can result in the deportation of genuine refugees. A 17-year-old boy from Syria whom we met
in Fylakio had what appeared to be a credible claim as a refugee. Despite alleging that he
had been subject to persecution in Syria, he told Human Rights Watch that he did not want
to apply for refugee status because the Greek police had told him that this would prolong his
detention. He also said that the police had recorded his date of birth as two years older than
he told them, thus rendering him as an “adult,” despite him stating that he was a child. Out
of fear, misinformation, and distrust he initially lied about his national identity:
My brother had political problems in Syria, and therefore spent a long time
as a political prisoner in Syria. The Mukhabarat [secret security police] also
took my father and spoke with me as well. I also had bad economic
problems and often did not have enough to eat in Syria.
I was 24 days in Venna. The Greeks already released all the people that came
with me, and I don't know why they are continuing to hold me here. The
smugglers told me to write down that I'm Palestinian, but now I'm still here.
121
Human Rights Watch interview with Haralampos Vomvellis, commander in Tychero Police Detention facility, November 30,
2010. The charges in question are criminal charges for illegal entry to Greece.
122 Interview with Arias Fernández, Orestiada, December 1, 2010.
123 Stuck in a Revolving Door, pp. 86-91.
THE EU’S DIRTY HANDS
42
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents