152
Europe and Central Asia
Summary of Amnesty International’s Concerns in the Region, January – June 2007
prompted them from their initial signed
statements to the police.
He also
reportedly interrupted Umida Niazova
repeatedly while she questioned witnesses.
Access to the trial was restricted.
Both articles carry possible prison terms of
up to 10 years.
On 8 May Umida Niazova was released from
the court-room after a judge changed her
seven-year sentence on appeal to a threeyear suspended one.
Umida Niazova
pleaded guilty to all three charges during
the
appeal
hearing
and
accused
international
organizations,
and
in
particular HRW, of having misled her. AI
expressed its dismay at the way her release
had been obtained.
Gulbahor Turaeva, a pathologist and human
rights activist from Andizhan, who in 2005
had spoken out to foreign media and
questioned the official version of the
Andizhan May 2005 events was detained on
14 January at the border on her way back
from neighbouring Kyrgyzstan, reportedly
carrying around 120 publications in her
bags, including books by the exiled leader
of the banned secular opposition Erk party.
On 24 April 2007, convicted of attempting
to overthrow the constitutional order, and
distributing subversive materials, she was
sentenced to six years in prison by the
Andizhan regional court.
She was also
charged
with
defamation,
allegedly
following a request by a teacher in
Andizhan, and following a second trial on 7
May 2007 was found guilty and sentenced
to a fine. Original reports had alleged that
she had been given an additional five-year
prison sentence; however, the authorities
issued an official statement denying this.
AI considered Gulbahor Turaeva to be a
prisoner of conscience, detained solely for
carrying out her human rights work, and
called for her immediate and unconditional
release. At the time of her detention she
was accompanied by her nine-year-old son,
who reportedly spent one night in detention
with her. Gulbahor Turaeva’s supporters
claimed that the literature she was carrying
did not contain calls for the violent
overthrow of the constitutional system.
They also claimed that it was difficult to
know which materials were banned in
Uzbekistan since there was no official
published list of banned publications.
Umida Niazova had been detained on 22
January 2007 in the south-east of the
country, near the border with Kyrgyzstan
and later transferred to the pre-trial
detention facility in Tashkent prison. She
was due to meet her lawyer that day, in
Tashkent, in order to collect her laptop and
passport which had been confiscated from
her in December 2006 by police who
detained her for nine hours as she returned
from a human rights seminar in Kyrgyzstan.
At that time, no criminal charges were
brought but she had to sign an undertaking
not to leave the country and to cooperate
with prosecutors in their investigation into
possible offences committed by her, namely
possession of anti-state materials on her
laptop computer. Her laptop was sent for
expert examination to establish whether
any materials stored on it were of a
"subversive or extremist" nature. Some of
the materials contained on the laptop were
said to be reports by HRW, namely its
published report on the Andizhan mass
killings in May 2005. Umida Niazova was
working for HRW’s office in Tashkent as a
translator. She had previously worked for
the international freedom of expression
NGOs, Internews and Freedom House.
On 28 January Umida Niazova was charged
under Article 223 of the Uzbekistani
Criminal Code for illegally crossing the
Uzbekistani border and under Article 246
for smuggling literature of a "subversive"
and "extremist" nature into the country.
Amnesty International
Gulbahor Turaeva
Gulbahor Turaeva worked as a forensic
pathologist in Andizhan. During the
Andizhan events, she reported to human
rights organizations and foreign media that
she had seen hundreds of dead bodies in
makeshift morgues – figures repudiated by
the authorities.
She was reportedly
involved in compiling an unofficial list of
those killed. She became a human rights
AI Index: EUR 01/010/2007
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents