Duration of Detention
Human Rights Watch has not managed to identify any coherent rationale for why
children are detained for longer or shorter periods. On Lesvos Island, where a
majority of children interviewed by Human Rights Watch entered Greece, the length
of their detention appears to be dependent on how many days prior to a “release
day”–the day authorities process migrant’s release from detention–a child entered
the country. The day Human Rights Watch visited Lesvos Island authorities released
a group of unaccompanied boys who had spent between three and 12 days in
detention.161 A care center for unaccompanied children opened on the island in July
2008 and offers police officials an alternative to detaining them. Despite this
available alternative, authorities continue to hold children behind bars for several
weeks and in conditions that are far below minimum standards.162
Twelve-year-old Sharzad P. and her 16-year-old brother Sardar P. from Afghanistan
were detained in the Kyprinou facility in Fylakio when we interviewed them:
We have been here for 65 days.… Someone informed us that we would
stay here for three months, the police told me that. We don’t agree to
stay for three months.… I want to be released and I don’t want to stay
longer.163
Twelve-year-old Sharzad P. shared her cell with about six adult women with whom
she was unable to communicate. Before being detained for more than two months in
that facility, the two siblings told us they had been held in a border police station for
11 days. Their temporary guardian had not been informed164 during that time and the
chief of police in Orestiada told us that migrants would usually spend only “two to
three days” in border police stations. Twelve-year-old Sharzad P. described that
161
We were not granted access to the detention center on Lesvos Island despite several requests.
162
Human Rights Watch telephone interview with various contact persons in July, August and September 2008 (names
withheld). We were not able to assess whether the detention of unaccompanied children on Samos Island goes beyond what
is strictly necessary before they are transferred to Lesvos. In the absence of any care center on Samos Island, children’s
detention could only be justified if it remains strictly limited in time and if authorities make a real effort to transfer children as
quickly as possible to alternative care.
163
Human Rights Watch interview with Sharzad P. and Sardar P., Fylakio detention center, May 25, 2008.
164
Human Rights Watch interview with Filippos Karatzidis, deputy prosecutor, Orestiada, May 26, 2008. For a discussion of
the guardianship system, see chapter II.
55
Human Rights Watch December 2008
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents