something more the police would kick me out without documents. I
was scared. I was then told to step to the side for fingerprints. The
Iranian woman said two or three times that I should say I came for a
better life. The interview took five minutes.137
He told Human Rights Watch that he had fled from Afghanistan on his own at the age
of 13 because he was threatened by a local commander:
There was a commander. His name was (he whispers) [name withheld].
Always when I went to work – they stopped me and told me to come
with them. This person wanted to keep underage boys for dancing and
more. I got scared and left Afghanistan. At that time I was 13 years old.
I went to Iran alone.… My father is old. The commander threatened me
and said if I complained to anybody he would kill me. He had two
other boys who were underage with him.… When the government of
Iran decided to deport Afghans I was afraid to go back and I decided to
move to Europe.… You can speak to anybody in [location withheld] and
ask about [name of commander withheld]. He’s a very bad person and
everybody knows him.138
Even though authorities are obliged to take into consideration child-specific forms of
persecution when children file asylum applications, Hamed P. was not given a
chance to explain the circumstances behind his escape from Afghanistan.139 The
UNHCR guidelines for assessing asylum applications by Afghan nationals specifically
mention that unaccompanied children continue to be exposed to exploitation and
that there are cases of boys who are abducted for sexual exploitation.140
137
Human Rights Watch interview with Hamed P., Athens, June 4, 2008.
138
Human Rights Watch interview with Hamed P., Athens, June 4, 2008.
139
Presidential Decree 96/2008, art. 9.2(f). Scholars argue that the recent jurisprudence expanded the meaning of
persecution to include several child-specific forms, such as child abuse, child sale and trafficking, or vulnerabilities arising
out of being a street child. Also, certain behavior (such as the witnessing the death of close relatives) do not rise to the
threshold of persecution for an adult but may do so for a child. See Jacqueline Bhabha, “Children, Migration and International
Norms,” in: T. Alexander Aleinikoff & Vincent Chetail, Migration and International Legal Norms, T.M.C.Asser Press, The Hague,
2003, p. 217.
140
UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), “UNHCR’s eligibility guidelines for assessing the international protection
needs of Afghan asylum seekers,” Afghanistan, December 2007, http://www.unhcr.org/cgibin/texis/vtx/refworld/rwmain?docid=477ce70a2&page=search (accessed August 26, 2008) pp.64-72. The guidelines
49
Human Rights Watch December 2008
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents