Neither of these boys, nor any other person we have spoken to attempted to file a
complaint about the behavior of port police officers. When we asked Ghulam S.
whether he had tried to lodge a complaint, he said: “there was nobody to complain
to.” 97
Indeed, the way in which the authorities investigated the multiple stabbing of 14year-old Ismail F., an unaccompanied child from Afghanistan, inside the port
premises in November 2007, reinforces the rationality of Ghulam S.’s perspective.
According to various sources, a person in uniform stabbed Ismail F. several times
with a sharp object while he was hiding under a truck.98 He was taken to a hospital
and received medical treatment. A medical examination of the boy’s injuries first
concluded that the boy had been hit by a blunt and heavy object. Two months later
the hospital revised the medical report to conclude his injuries were caused by a
sharp object.99 The Hellenic Red Cross provided legal assistance to the boy and to a
second witness who was also underage and helped them to file a complaint.100 The
case was also brought to the attention of the Greek Ombudsman.
During a pre-investigation by the responsible office of the Ministry of Mercantile
Marine, the two boys were asked to identify the perpetrator from among only two
officers presented to them. No victim protection mechanism was put in place and the
boys were visible during the identification procedure. They did not identify either
officer as a perpetrator. They were also not referred to any safe housing by the state
for the duration of the investigation.
97
Human Rights Watch interview with Ghulam S., Athens, June 5, 2008. Human Rights Watch was unable to meet with the
port police in Patras on June 9. We brought allegations of ill-treatment against the Patras port police to the attention of the
Minister of Mercantile Marine in a letter and called for an investigation. We had not received any reply from the Ministry when
this report went to print.
98
Human Rights Watch interview in Patras, June 9, 2008 (exact name withheld); Human Rights Watch interviews with refugee
rights activists in Athens on May 22, and June 5, 2008 (exact names withheld); Human Rights Watch interview with Greek
Ombudsman office, Athens, June 10, 2008.
99
The Greek Ombudsman strongly criticized the Patras hospital’s initial wrong diagnosis of the object that caused the boy’s
injuries. In a letter to the hospital, the Greek Ombudsman argues that this wrong examination had a direct impact on the
investigation and disciplinary and penal responsibilities. Human Rights Watch has a copy of the letter on file.
100
Human Rights Watch interview, Patras, June 9, 2008 (exact name withheld); Human Rights Watch interviews with refugee
rights activists in Athens, May 22, and June 5, 2008 (exact names withheld).
35
Human Rights Watch December 2008
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents