1. INTRODUCTION
Recent years have seen countless reports of pushbacks at Greece’s land
and sea borders with Turkey. The Greek
state continuously fails to launch adequate investigations or accept responsibility despite their complicity in these
illegal operations being well-documented. The findings of this report demonstrate that pushback operations and
the concomitant targeting of those
working to defend the rights of victims
in Greece are not isolated incidents,
but an unofficial migration and border
policy implemented by Greek state actors and their auxiliaries.
To shed light on this systematic state
policy, the report firstly recounts pushback cases in the Evros border region,
brought before the European Court of
Human Rights (ECtHR) between March
2022 and October 2022. The report
then presents two pushback cases that
occurred in the Eastern Aegean islands,
that are significant as in both cases
some of the pushback victims managed
to re-enter Greece and file official complaints before the Public Prosecutor. All
of the cases included in this report are
legally represented by GCR and submitted before the ECtHR and/or the Public
Prosecutor. The details presented herein are based on the testimonies of the
pushback victims.
By detailing the multiple similar testimonies of pushback victims in Greece,
combined with evidence of pushbacks
outlined in relevant reports and publications, this report aims to firstly
4
demonstrate that said illegal practices
constitute a systematic, meticulously
planned and comprehensive policy of
the Greek state, involving multiple actors and operational steps. Moreover,
this report aims to counteract the argument perpetuated by Greek and EU authorities, that there is a lack of evidence
on the existence and/ or perpetrators of
pushbacks, which has led to a situation
of chronic impunity for the perpetrators and a lack of access to justice for
victims of these rights violations at Europe’s borders. Furthermore, this report
sheds light on the Turkish authorities’
involvement in the violent management
of asylum seekers in the Evros region,
leading to the conclusion that the policies of multiple EU and non-EU state
authorities are at play in these rights violations at the EU’s external border.
Lastly, this report also highlights another aspect of the Greek state’s
policy of deterrence and violence
against those seeking protection at its
borders, i.e. the systematic targeting
of human rights defenders (HRDs),
by presenting in detail the intimidation and attempted criminalisation of
HRDs involved in legal actions to support the pushback victims of the cases
presented in the report.
We hope that this report will contribute
to ending the ongoing impunity of those
perpetrating grave human rights violations against migrants and refugees
seeking protection in Europe, as well as
the increasing attempts to silence and
intimidate human rights defenders.
AT EUROPE’S BORDERS: BETWEEN IMPUNITY AND CRIMINALIZATION