the reinstatement of transfers would be lawful.94 The Commission will submit its own assessment of the legality of
Dublin transfers in June 2016.95
Yet such a reinstatement of Dublin transfers to Greece would prove problematic in more than one respect. Firstly,
a state of affairs whereby international protection applicants are transferred out of Greece under the emergency
relocation scheme (which still operates at very meagre levels), while others are returned to Greece under Dublin,
would be highly counter-intuitive to the aim of alleviating pressure on the Greek asylum system; similar flaws in
previous relocation schemes such as the intra-EU Relocation from Malta (EUREMA) pilot project would testify to
this.96 Quite to the contrary, it could result in placing Greek authorities under even more severe strain in view of
the number of asylum seekers who are potentially returnable under the Dublin Regulation. The class of potential
returnees should not be underestimated, recalling that out of 856,723 persons arriving by sea in the country in
2015,97 only 13,197 (about 1.5%) applied for international protection,98 while during the first two months of this
year, only 2,641 persons (less than 2.1%)99 applied for asylum out of a total 126,166 arrivals by sea.100 UNHCR’s
recommendation to return people to Greece under Dublin in order for them to apply for relocation – and thus be
transferred out again – is an equally flawed proposition.101
Secondly, bearing in mind the possibility of a legislative proposal for a substantial revision of the Dublin Regulation
announced to be tabled by the Commission in April 2016, to push for the reinstatement of transfers to Greece
would effectively mean to reinforce the operation of a responsibility-allocation mechanism widely recognised as
faulty. If the defects of the current Dublin system have been acknowledged by courts, Member States and the
Commission itself, ahead of a legislative overhaul, there seems little reason to take drastic measures to enforce
them shortly before they disappear. In that sense, the intention to restore Dublin “normalcy” in the case of Greece
does not find justification in protection or solidarity rationales.
1.2. Reception along the Balkan route
As regards the creation of 50,000 places along the Balkan route, the Commission reported on 10 February 2016
that “around half of this figure is currently available or being developed”.102
Serbia committed to creating 6,000 additional reception places by the end of 2015.103 However, as of the end of
February 2016, no official steps had been taken for the creation of additional facilities, as political discussions on
the issue had not yet led to concrete measures.104 Reception places for asylum seekers remain at a total of 1,060
in the existing 5 Asylum Centres throughout the country.
Croatia, for its part, announced the establishment of 5,000 reception places.105 However, the only accommodation
facility delivered since that commitment is the Temporary Admission Centre in Slavonski Brod. On one hand, this
centre was already foreseen prior to the Western Balkan Summit as a winterisation measure to replace the one
operating in Opatovac.106 On the other hand, Slavonski Brod can host up to 5,000 persons, yet only for very short
stays; as explained by the Croatian Ministry of Interior, the centre aims to provide shelter for migrants for one to two
days.107 In that light, Croatia’s limited capacity to accommodate asylum seekers in the longer term has remained
unaffected at a total of 700 places in two Reception Centres for Asylum Seekers.
94.
95.
96.
97.
98.
99.
100.
101.
102.
103.
104.
105.
106.
107.
24
European Commission, Implementing the European Agenda on Migration: Progress on Priority Actions, IP/16/271, 10
February 2016.
European Commission, Back to Schengen – A Roadmap, COM(2016) 120, 4 March 2016, 8.
See EASO, Fact-finding report on intra-EU relocation activities from Malta, July 2012, available at: http://bit.ly/1Xnu88x.
UNHCR, Refugees/Migrants Emergency Response – Mediterranean.
Greek Asylum Service, Asylum Statistics 2015, available at: http://bit.ly/1OukycW.
Greek Asylum Service, Asylum Statistics February 2016, available at: http://bit.ly/1TYwc2Z.
UNHCR, Refugees/Migrants Emergency Response – Mediterranean.
See UNHCR, Stabilizing the situation of refugees and migrants: Proposal to the Meeting of EU Heads of State or Government and Turkey on 7 March 2016, 4 March 2016, available at: http://bit.ly/1pq4mla, 2-3.
European Commission, Implementing the European Agenda on Migration: Progress on Priority Actions, IP/16/271, 10
February 2016.
European Commission, Progress following Western Balkans Route Leaders’ Meeting: Contact Points Video Conference, IP/15/5952, 29 October 2015; Second Contact Points Video Conference, IP/15/6003, 5 November 2015.
AIDA Country Report Serbia, March 2016, 27-28.
European Commission, Progress following Western Balkans Route Leaders’ Meeting: Contact Points Video Conference, IP/15/5952, 29 October 2015; Second Contact Points Video Conference, IP/15/6003, 5 November 2015.
Croatian Ministry of Interior, October 2015: Reception and accommodation of migrants, 21 October 2015, available at:
http://bit.ly/1p1xjmX. See also ECRE, Western Balkans News Brief 30 October – 6 November 2015.
Ibid.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents