per their domestic legal basis.32 These are likely to be modelled based on the First Reception Centre (formerly First Reception Centre) of Evros, which has been operational since 2014 and – contrary to its title – hosts migrants and asylum seekers in a state of detention.33 In fact, the amended legal framework of first reception procedures clarifies that migrants are subject to restriction of freedom of movement within the premises of these centres.34 Insofar as they deprive migrants of their liberty, these structures should be viewed as detention rather than reception facilities in both legal and practical terms. This conceptual uncertainty is nevertheless reflected in the European Commission’s assessment of “reception capacity”, which in the case of Greece seems to present detention facilities as reception structures.35 The Hotspot Progress Reports on Greece, issued in December 2015 and February 2016 and discussed in detail in Chapter II, Section 1, do so even though they already specifically refer to “pre-removal [detention] capacity”. Under an appropriate understanding of the conditions prevailing in Reception and Identification Centres, detention capacity in the “hotspots” is therefore misrepresented as reception capacity. A “hotspot”-like approach already existed in Bulgaria, where asylum applicants who have made applications at the border are promptly referred to Elhovo, a “short-holding” or “triage” centre. Here the applicants are registered and screened in conditions of detention for an average of 12 days, although the length of time held in detention differs considerably according to the nationality of the applicant. Applicants are then either transferred to one of the four reception centres in the country or re-allocated to the pre-removal centres in instances where asylum has not been claimed or where capacity in Elhovo is exceeded. The delays of 12 days have been attributed to a lack of coordination between the border police and the State Agency for Refugees, the body responsible for registering asylum applications in Bulgaria.36 In dereliction of the necessity and proportionality assessments when analysing the legality of detention under the recast Reception Conditions Directive as well as Article 6 of the recast Asylum Procedures Directive, detention which is seemingly imposed for administrative convenience without any requisite safeguards is legally untenable. Additionally, as of 1 January 2016, domestic legislation in Bulgaria allows for the detention of asylum seekers on grounds listed in the recast Reception Conditions Directive.37 Detention is foreseen to be carried out in ‘closed departments’ within the existing reception centres. Similarly, the newly introduced Initial Reception Centres in Malta are described as a “contained environment”, entrusted with the first-line reception of all irregular entrants according to a revised government strategy for the reception and detention of asylum seekers and migrants.38 Irregularly arriving foreign nationals are thus channelled into an Initial Reception Centre for short stays, prior to the authorities’ decision on whether to detain them or host them in open reception centres. Two such centres have been set up so far, yet NGOs have expressed concern around the risks of living conditions therein amounting to deprivation of liberty in practice.39 If so, this facility should also be conceptually distinct from reception centres in the country. In other countries such as Croatia, detention centres are factually distinct from reception centres for asylum seekers but are euphemistically branded as “Reception Centres for Foreigners”.40 Under the law, a person is not expressly detained but only “accommodated” in such a centre,41 thereby potentially adding to confusion. For its part, the facility in which irregular migrants are detained in Serbia is named “Shelter for Foreigners”.42 Against the backdrop of divergent institutional arrangements and conceptualisations of reception obligations across Europe, it becomes highly difficult to establish comparable standards with a view to assessing Member 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. Greek Joint Ministerial Decision 2969/2015 “Establishment of First Reception Centres and temporary Accommodation Facilities for asylum seekers and vulnerable groups of third-country nationals”, Official Gazzette 2602/B/2-12-2015. For Chios and Samos, see also Greek Joint Ministerial Decision 6634/1-147524, Official Gazette 10/B/8-1-2016. See also Article 6 Greek Law 3907/2011, as proposed for amendment in February 2016. For a discussion, see ECRE, What’s in a name? The reality of first “reception” at Evros, February 2015, available at: http://bit.ly/1GfXIzk. Article 12(2) Greek Law 3907/2011, as proposed for amendment in February 2016. European Commission, Progress Report on the Implementation of the hotspots in Greece (hereafter “Hotspot Progress Report Greece”), COM(2015) 678, 15 December 2015, 13. AIDA Country Report Bulgaria: Fourth Update, October 2015, 52-53. Amendments to the Law on the Asylum and Refugees, published in the State Gazette on 16 October 2015, accessible at: http://bit.ly/1Q7Fjc8. Maltese Ministry of Home Affairs and National Security, Strategy for the reception of asylum seekers and irregular migrants, December 2015, available at: http://bit.ly/1Wb3Cej, 10. AIDA Country Report Malta: Fourth Update, November 2015, 41. Information provided by the aditus foundation, 9 March 2016. Article 54(4) Croatian Law on International and Temporary Protection. See also AIDA Country Report Croatia: Second Update, December 2015, 54. Ibid. AIDA Country Report Serbia, March 2016, 35. 13

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents