ficers or during identity checks or raids in their
shelters. The vast majority of those arrested
are released after one or two days. In all of the
cases either the coast guard or police officers
are alleged to have perpetrated ill-treatment,
inflicting physical injury or psychological trauma on individual arrestees for the purpose of
deterrence, terror and humiliation.
The allegations of torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment, which are documented in this report, raise concerns about the
systematic use of physical force by law enforcement officers against migrants and refugees.
There seems to be a failure of the authorities
to ensure that legal provisions guaranteeing
the protection of migrants and refugees during arrest are implemented. The scale of allegations concerning police violence indicates a
widespread pattern rather than a few isolated
incidents. Furthermore, this pattern suggests
a wider policy of repression and fear executed
by law enforcement officers, which is aimed at
discouraging undocumented migrants and refugees from coming to the port cities and trying to reach Europe through these “gates”. As
one of the interviewees told us: “They want to
force us out of Patras!” 5
Fascist graffiti at the southern port of Patras
6
Such treatment constitutes a serious abuse of
the hierarchical power relationship between
state officials and the sans-papiers and refugees,
which is likely to persist as a result of the ongoing “climate of impunity within law enforcement agencies”. 6
These abuses are combined with the absence of
access to asylum in Greece, access to information, inadequate reception conditions (housing,
nutrition, medical treatment etc.), the lack of
humanitarian aid and the total deprivation of
rights faced by migrants and refugees in Patras (but also in Athens and other places all
over Greece), which have further contributed
to their dehumanisation, marginalisation and
exclusion. Migrants and refugees are being targeted and ill-treated by state officials precisely
because they are migrants and refugees – and
also because they are foreigners (“ξενοι”).
A press release from the Racist Violence
Recording Network on February 21, 2012 highlighted the overlaps between racist and police
violence. Over a period of three months (October - December 2011), the Network cited eight
incidents of racist attacks by state agents in
Patras:
„I have to change my luck!“
5 Interview held on May 4, 2012
6 CPT 2008
“There is a distinct category consisting of 18 incidents,
where police and racist violence are interlinked (10
in Athens and 8 in Patras). These incidents concern
duty police officers, who resorted to illegal acts and
violent practices while carrying out routine operations. There are a few recorded cases of migrants
and asylum seekers taken to police stations, where
they were detained and maltreated during a certain
number of hours, as well as cases where legal documents were destroyed during these operations.” 7
We see a clear relationship between the social discrimination of migrants in Greece, racist
violence and police violence, which reinforce
each other by creating through action and propaganda a category of marginalised and rightless non-citizens, as “the other” or an “enemy
within”.
Bearing in mind that hundreds of migrants and refugees are trapped in Greece, and
particularly in Patras, we hope that this report
will contribute to a better understanding of
their situation in Patras as well as the roots of
racism in this city.
“You who are looking at us now, once will get hungry as we are
now!” In the early 1990s, this was the parole of the protesting
employees of Peiraiki Patraiki factory, when it closed its doors.
It has been once Greece’s largest textile producer owning also
factories in Sudan.
1.1. Methodology
Pro Asyl in co-operation with the Greek Council For Refugees, conducted research in the port
city of Patras during April (2.4-5.4) and May
(11.5-15.5) 2012 8. During these missions the
team visited various sites, where undocumented migrants and asylum seekers live while “in
transit”. 9
Thirty-one individual interviews were
conducted with victims of ill-treatment by
state agents. Eleven of them were unaccompanied minors. Anonymity was a crucial precondition for the report, in order to protect the
interviewees. Interviews were held in Dari, Arabic, English and French. In addition, the team
held group discussions with larger numbers
of migrants and refugees as well as meetings
with staff from the NGO Praksis, the Greek Red
Cross and the UNHCR, and the solidarity group
“Kinisi” – Motion for the defence of refugees’
and migrants’ rights – who work with migrants
and refugees in Patras, in order to confirm the
information collected.
Because of the delicate subject matter, the
precarious living conditions of the migrants
and refugees in Patras, the transitory nature of
the makeshift camps they live in, their permanent fear and feeling of being persecuted, the
lack of any institutional protection, the high
level of mistrust expressed by some of them
towards the team (and any “outsiders” in general), and the difficult environment in which
these interviews were conducted (outside areas), the team recommends that the physical
and psychological violence to which migrants
have been subjected by the Greek authorities
both inside and outside the detention centres
in Patras warrants further investigation and
documentation.
This report contains the exact testimony of the
victims themselves. Dozens of other migrants
interviewed by the team also confirmed that
few migrants and refugees in Patras have not
been victims of police violence and ill-treatment, at least once and often on repeated occasions.
The large number of cases and the similarity
between so many of these testimonies suggests a systematic pattern of violence.
7 http://www.1againstracism.gr/index.php/en/component/k2/
itemlist/category/26-racist-violence-recording-network
8 The Team consisted of two lawyers (M. Tzeferakou and K.
Tsapopoulou), a social anthropologist / interpreter for Farsi
and an interpreter for Arabic.
9 We visited the following places: Peiraiki Patraiki Factory,
olive fields near Rio