2.6. The Lack of protection for
unaccompanied minors
are not properly informed about the exams they
undergo or the procedure. Furthermore they
were not informed about the result of the medical
examinations they underwent, the considerable
margin of error was not evaluated and they do
According to Praksis, a Greek NGO running a not have the chance to challenge such a decision.
program concerning minors in the port of Patras, One of the minors interviewed, clearly told us that
from September 2011 until today (June 2012) they although he saw that the age written down on his
were contacted by the Greek port authorities in 19 paper in the hospital by the doctor, stated that he
cases of readmitted unaccompanied minors.
is 16 years old, he was readmitted back to Greece.
In general, most of the returned unaccompanied
minors are Afghans. According to what most of the
interviewees stated, the Italian authorities usually
estimate the age of those arriving at the Italian
ports by “looking at the person”. We have been
told repeatedly of minor cases being registered as
adults. In one case, we were informed about a 10–
years old minor, who was readmitted from Bari to
Patras in November 2011, registered by the Italian
authorities as an 18 years old!
In some other cases allegedly, even when the
children clearly said that they were minors, they
were not registered as such. It seems as if the
age determination depends exclusively on the
discretion of the Italian authorities. In another
case, a minor allegedly showed his documents from
Greece proofing his age and the Italian officers tore
it up. Others told us, that they were not even asked
about their age by the authorities.
An unaccompanied minor who had been readmitted
once in the past described that on his second
attempt he arrived at the port of Venice, and was
‘lucky’ this time, since he was severely injured upon
his arrival by a truck which drove over him. He
assumes that due to his injuries and his consequent
stay in a hospital, he was not readmitted at that
time.27
In those rare cases, minors reported that they
were transferred to the hospital for medical
examination, a wrist X-ray was also taken.28 Children
27
Field-notes: April 17 and April 18, 2012
28
The use of X-rays and other methods that expose minors
to useless and dangerous radiation is highly problematic from a
legal and a medical point of view. Concerning the health risks of radiation the Royal College of Radiologists in London in 1996 stated,
12
There have also been documented cases of minors
separated from their family by the readmission
procedure. In one case, two alleged minor brothers
were separated. One was readmitted as an adult
and the other stayed in Italy. In another case a
minor who managed to reach Italy informed the
authorities about his brother who is legally residing
in Italy, but was not allowed to contact him. In some
other cases of interviewed unaccompanied minors,
even though they informed the Italian authorities
that their families are residing in other European
countries, no measures to locate their families or
relatives were initiated.
Concerns also arise about health risks resulting
form the use of scanners for the detection of
irregular migrants hiding in trucks especially in the
cases of minors.29 30
that it is “unjustified” to undertake a radiograph examination
for age estimation purposes on alleged minor refugees. It is not
acceptable to expose children to ionizing radiation for an examination, which has no therapeutic benefit and is purely for administrative purposes.
29
Italy has installed 28 networked X-ray scanners located at
its major national ports of which the ones in Ancona, Bari, Brindisi
and Venice are all of the type “Silhouette 300”. These scanners
are dual-energy x-ray devices up to 450 keV operating in continuous exposure mode - fluoroscopic mode (also known as Silhouette
Mobile Scanner). The same types of images are produced with
gamma ray scanning technology operating in the same manner.
These scanners are deployed to inspect interior of vehicles crossing
the border. http://www.donggok.co.kr/data/SilhouetteScan.pdf
30
In France using x-rays to find people is banned in case the
radiation damages their health, even though it emits X-ray levels
similar to a hospital machine. See: French ban X-ray scans for illegal
immigrants as radiation makes them ‘too dangerous’
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1278565/
French-ban-X-ray-scans-illegal-immigrants-radiation-makes-dangerous.html#ixzz1xO9WgJIJ, See also: Health dangers by x-rays
http://www.pnas.org/content/83/13/4839.abstract
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents