D. Developments
during 1st
quarter of 2017
both Greek and EU level.
Finally, the European Commission Recommendation of
7.3.2017 on making returns more effective,222 creates a
new landscape for the implementation of substantial and
procedural safeguards in practice and the Ombudsman will
closely monitor the implementation of the national policies
at each stage of the process, in order to protect the fundamental rights of the involved third-country nationals.
4. Housing
The living conditions in the temporary accommodation
facilities and the hotspots have improved in 2017,
especially following the bad weather conditions of the winter
of 2016-2017, which were an opportunity for highlighting
the inadequacy or unsuitability of many installations, often
with tragic consequences for the people living there.
The positive developments include the evacuation of particularly problematic accommodation sites, the replacement
of most tents with stable constructions and the decrease of
the population staying in mass accommodation sites, with
the movement of mainly vulnerable groups to other forms
of housing (apartments, hotels, etc.). The accommodation
program of the UNHCR, in cooperation with NGOs and municipalities has provided 19,139223 accommodation places
in apartments, hotels, buildings, as well as hospitality by
families. This fact is especially positive, since beyond the
good accommodation conditions, this form of accommodation fosters social integration.
However, there are still significant shortages in material and
technical infrastructure in many mass accommodation sites.
In particular, an unspecified number of people224 is still living in tents (Samos, Souda in Chios), whereas the essential
amenities, such as heating, electricity and sanitary facilities are not always ensured (e.g. Chios (VIAL), Polykastro in
Kilkis, etc.). Also, accommodation sites are still in operation
in old industrial buildings, which pose risks for the health
of the residents (e.g. Kalohori in Thessaloniki, Oinofyta in
Viotia, etc.).
222 https://ec.europa.eu/home-affairs/sites/homeaffairs/files/what-we-do/
policies/european-agenda-migration/20170302_commission_recommendation_
on_making_returns_more_effective_en.pdf
223 UNHCR data as of 28.3.2017.
224 Despite the Ombudsman's relevant investigation, it could not obtain any
official information regarding the exact number of people living in tents.
76
Finally, the official establishment of the Reception and Accommodation Facilities and the issue of their General Rules
of Operation are still pending.
5. Health
The initial investigation of the Ombudsman on the tragic incident of the death of a detainee suffering from hepatitis at
the Pre-removal Center of Tavros on 6.2.2017, confirmed
the fact that the examination and filling-in of the health card
is not done immediately for all new arrivals at the Detention
Center, considering that it is supported by only one doctor
of the Hellenic Center for Disease Control & Prevention,
5 days a week during working hours. The Ombudsman observes that the findings of the Council of Europe Committee for the Prevention of Torture still apply today regarding
the lack of an integrated approach in the provision of health
services to the detainees during its visit in 2015 at the Tavros Detention Center on P. Ralli Str.225 Thus, the Ombudsman's recommendation for the immediate care and systematic monitoring of the health of all administratively detained
third-country nationals, as stipulated by the relevant regulatory provisions is still valid (see Chapter B3).
6. Education
A more general observation regarding the picture presented
in early 2017, is that the Ministry of Education continues to
make efforts to assure the right to education of the children
from third countries, without however having covered the
gaps or addressed many of the procedural problems that
emerge. Specifically:
6.1. Operation
of DYEPs
In early 2017, there were approximately half of the stipulated DYEPs in operation, and operational and other problems that had initially emerged had been addressed,226
whereas an elementary expertise in the field had been acquired, a fact that contributed to a gradually improving operation of the DYEP programme.
225 http://hudoc.cpt.coe.int/eng#{"CPTState":["GRC"],"CPTSectionID":["p-grc20150414-en-26"]} report about the visit in 2015 to Greece, published in July
2016, see D. 117.
226 We indicatively mention problems of negative reactions by the benefited
populations and leaks, issues related to health and safety, difficulties that emerged
during the transportation of the children to the DYEPs with vehicles, problems
due to the wrong initial declaration of the child's age resulting in including it in the
wrong grade, etc.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents